The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has upheld a ruling in a sexual harassment case involving Meng Huang, a former graduate student at The Ohio State University (OSU), and her advisor, Professor Giorgio Rizzoni. The court's decision, issued on November 17, 2026, affirms the jury's verdict that found in favor of Rizzoni and dismissed Huang's claims against OSU.
This ruling is significant as it highlights the complexities surrounding sexual harassment claims in academic settings, particularly regarding the definitions of employment and the responsibilities of universities in such cases. The outcome affects not only Huang but also sets a precedent for how similar cases might be handled in the future.
Background
Meng Huang enrolled at OSU to pursue a Ph.D. in engineering and worked at the university's Center for Automotive Research, where Rizzoni served as her advisor. Huang alleged that Rizzoni engaged in unwelcome sexual conduct and used his authority to coerce her into compliance. She claimed that after resisting his advances, Rizzoni retaliated by manipulating her candidacy exam, ultimately leading to her failure.
In response, Rizzoni denied Huang's allegations, asserting that her academic struggles were due to her lack of focus and effort. The case first reached the courts when Huang filed a lawsuit against both Rizzoni and OSU, claiming Title VII violations for retaliation and quid pro quo sexual harassment, as well as a § 1983 claim against Rizzoni for violating her Fourteenth Amendment rights.
The district court initially granted summary judgment for OSU, ruling that Huang was not an employee under Title VII, and allowed the § 1983 claim to proceed to trial, where a jury sided with Rizzoni. Huang appealed, leading to a previous ruling by the Sixth Circuit that vacated the summary judgment and ordered a new trial.
The Ruling
During the second trial, the jury again ruled in favor of Rizzoni, concluding that neither he nor OSU had the right to control Huang's work, which led the district court to determine that Huang was not an employee of OSU for Title VII purposes. The court stated, “the jury returned a special verdict finding that neither OSU nor Rizzoni had the ‘right to control the manner and means by which Dr. Huang accomplished her work.’” This verdict extinguished Huang's claims against OSU.
Huang appealed the decision, raising several issues including the jury instructions regarding her employee status, the exclusion of evidence related to a campus climate survey on sexual assault, and limitations on her arguments about lost wages. However, the court found that Huang had forfeited her first challenge and that the other claims lacked merit, affirming the jury's verdict.
Impact
The court's ruling has significant implications for future sexual harassment cases, especially in academic environments. It underscores the importance of establishing employee status under Title VII for claims of sexual harassment and retaliation. The decision also illustrates the challenges plaintiffs may face in proving their cases, particularly when it comes to demonstrating the control exerted by their employers.
Moreover, the ruling may influence how universities handle allegations of sexual harassment and the protections they offer to students and employees. It emphasizes the need for clear definitions of employment status and the responsibilities of academic institutions in preventing and addressing harassment.
What's Next
As of now, it remains unclear whether Huang will seek further appeals following this ruling. There are no related cases pending that would directly impact this decision, but the outcome may inspire other students with similar claims to reconsider how they approach their cases in the future.
Read Next
Court upholds ruling in age discrimination case against school board
Court rules on police shooting case involving Casey Crowley
Sixth Circuit upholds jury verdict in Ford-InterMotive case
California court reverses summary judgment in job case
California court upholds Abortion Accessibility Act in ruling
Ninth Circuit affirms dismissal of sex trafficking case










