A California court has reversed a summary judgment in favor of Edwards Lifesciences LLC, affecting the case of Kari Anderson, who alleged pregnancy discrimination and retaliation against her former employer. The ruling emphasizes the importance of allowing sufficient time for discovery in employment discrimination cases.

The court's decision, filed on November 17, 2026, overturns a previous ruling by the Superior Court of Orange County, which had granted summary judgment to Edwards Lifesciences. This case is significant as it highlights the legal protections for employees facing discrimination related to pregnancy and the necessity for employers to provide reasonable accommodations.

Background

Kari Anderson filed her complaint against Edwards Lifesciences in March 2023. She alleged that she was wrongfully terminated after informing the company about her high-risk pregnancy and requesting accommodations in November 2022. Anderson's complaint included multiple causes of action under the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), which prohibits discrimination based on sex, gender, and disability.

Edwards Lifesciences responded by asserting that Anderson's position was eliminated for legitimate budgetary reasons. The company claimed that the decision to terminate Anderson was made before she disclosed her pregnancy. In response, Anderson filed a motion to compel further discovery related to the company's budget, which she believed was crucial for her case. However, the trial court denied her request for additional time to gather evidence and subsequently granted summary judgment to Edwards.

The Ruling

The California Court of Appeal found that the trial court erred in denying Anderson's request for additional time to conduct discovery. The court ruled that Anderson had made a good faith showing that essential facts existed that could justify her opposition to the summary judgment motion. The opinion stated, "The record does not establish the existence of good reason" for denying the continuance requested by Anderson.

The appellate court emphasized that under California law, continuance requests for additional discovery in summary judgment cases should be liberally granted. The court noted that Anderson's counsel had adequately explained the need for more time to obtain documents related to the budget, which could potentially establish a material question of fact regarding the timing of the decision to eliminate her position.

Impact

This ruling is significant for employees who may face discrimination in the workplace, particularly regarding pregnancy-related issues. It reinforces the notion that employers must provide reasonable accommodations and that employees should have the opportunity to gather evidence to support their claims. The decision also highlights the importance of timely access to relevant documents in employment disputes.

The ruling sets a precedent in California, emphasizing that trial courts must carefully consider requests for additional discovery time in summary judgment motions. It underscores the need for courts to allow employees the opportunity to present their cases fully, especially in situations involving potential discrimination.

What's Next

The case will return to the trial court, where the previous summary judgment in favor of Edwards Lifesciences will be vacated. Anderson will have the opportunity to gather the necessary evidence and potentially proceed with her claims against the company. It remains to be seen whether Edwards will appeal this decision or if there are related cases pending.