The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has upheld a lower court's decision to dismiss patent infringement claims filed by Touchmusic Entertainment LLC against Apple Inc. and Amazon Web Services, Inc. The court ruled that the claims were invalid because the patent in question had expired and the plaintiff did not have the right to sue for past damages. This ruling affects Touchmusic and its associated company, Ziklag IP LLC, which sought to enforce rights over a patent that had already lapsed.
The case, identified as 25-1733, was decided on November 19, 2026, and involved a dispute over U.S. Patent No. 6,182,128. The patent had expired in 2018, and the court found that Touchmusic's rights to pursue legal action were further complicated by the suspension of its corporate rights under California law at the time the lawsuits were filed. This situation left Ziklag, which was assigned certain rights from Touchmusic, without the necessary authority to pursue claims for past infringement.
Background
Touchmusic Entertainment LLC filed two separate complaints in the Northern District of Illinois on March 2, 2024. One complaint accused Apple Inc. of infringing the ’128 patent, while the other accused Amazon Web Services, Inc. of the same infringement. Both cases were assigned to Judge Steven C. Seeger.
Before the complaints were filed, the ’128 patent had expired nearly six years prior, on March 5, 2018. Additionally, when Touchmusic initiated these lawsuits, its corporate rights were suspended, which meant it was not legally permitted to file litigation. To navigate this issue, Touchmusic assigned certain rights of the patent to Ziklag and subsequently filed amended complaints to substitute Ziklag as the plaintiff.
Amazon and Apple responded by filing motions to dismiss the amended complaints. Amazon argued that Ziklag had not been granted the right to sue for past damages, which was crucial since the patent was already expired. On March 31, 2025, the district court agreed with Amazon and dismissed both cases with prejudice, meaning the claims could not be brought back to court.
The Ruling
The Federal Circuit ultimately affirmed the district court's decision. The court ruled that Ziklag was collaterally estopped from challenging the lower court's determination that it did not have the right to sue for past damages. The opinion stated, "Because Ziklag is collaterally estopped from challenging the district court’s holding that it cannot sue for past damages, we affirm."
This ruling was made by Circuit Judges Lourie, Stoll, and Stark. The court found that all necessary factors for collateral estoppel were met, meaning that Ziklag could not relitigate the issue of whether it had the right to sue for damages that occurred before it was assigned the patent rights.
Impact
The court's decision has significant implications for patent holders and companies involved in technology and intellectual property. It reinforces the principle that a patent holder cannot pursue claims for infringement after the patent has expired. Additionally, it highlights the importance of having clear and explicit rights in any assignment of patent rights, particularly regarding the ability to sue for past damages.
This ruling may deter similar cases where companies attempt to revive expired patent claims through corporate restructuring or assignment of rights. It also emphasizes the importance of maintaining corporate compliance to avoid losing the ability to litigate.
What's Next
Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether Ziklag plans to appeal this ruling. However, the company's options may be limited due to the affirmance of the lower court's decision and the established principles of collateral estoppel. There is also a related case pending involving Ziklag and Netflix, which was decided concurrently with this opinion, but Ziklag did not challenge the same assignment issue in that case.











