The Wisconsin Court of Appeals has upheld a lower court's decision to dismiss a claim for indemnification filed by Doniel Carter against the State of Wisconsin. This ruling, issued on November 19, 2026, affects Carter and his legal team, as well as the state agencies involved in the case, particularly the Department of Administration and the Department of Corrections. The court's decision underscores the limits of state liability in cases involving employee misconduct.
The case stems from a federal lawsuit in which Carter alleged that Erika Watson, a former correctional officer, sexually assaulted him while he was an inmate at Fox Lake Correctional Institution. After a jury found in favor of Carter, awarding him punitive damages, he sought to have the state indemnify Watson for the judgment. However, the court ruled that sovereign immunity barred this claim.
Background
Doniel Carter, along with the law firms Davey & Goldman and Cade Law Group, filed the appeal after the circuit court dismissed their complaint against the State of Wisconsin. The dispute originated from a federal court case where Carter claimed that Watson violated his Eighth Amendment rights. The federal jury ruled that Watson's actions warranted punitive damages but did not award compensatory damages.
In the federal proceedings, the Wisconsin Department of Justice did not represent Watson, as the allegations against her were deemed outside the scope of her employment. Following the trial, Carter and his attorneys sought to compel the state to indemnify Watson for the punitive damages awarded against her. They named Watson as an involuntary plaintiff in their complaint, arguing that this would allow them to circumvent the state's sovereign immunity.
The Ruling
The Wisconsin Court of Appeals, in a decision authored by Judge Kloppenburg, affirmed the lower court's dismissal of the complaint based on the principle of sovereign immunity. The court explained that under Wisconsin law, only state employees can seek indemnification from the state under WIS. STAT. § 895.46. As Watson did not pursue indemnification, the court ruled that Carter and his legal team could not bring a claim against the state.
The court stated, "We conclude that the circuit court properly dismissed Carter and counsel’s complaint because their claim under § 895.46 is barred by sovereign immunity."
The court further clarified that sovereign immunity prevents individuals from suing the state unless there is explicit legislative consent. Since the statute does not allow for a tort victim to directly sue the state for indemnification, the court found no merit in Carter's arguments.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for future cases involving claims against the state for indemnification of its employees. It reinforces the legal principle that sovereign immunity protects the state from being sued without its consent, particularly in cases where the employee has not sought indemnification. This decision may discourage other inmates or plaintiffs from attempting to seek similar indemnification claims against the state.
Legal experts note that the ruling highlights the limitations of WIS. STAT. § 895.46, which is designed to protect public employees rather than provide a pathway for tort victims to recover damages from the state. The court's interpretation of the statute emphasizes that indemnification is a right reserved for state employees acting within the scope of their employment.
What's Next
Following this ruling, Carter and his legal team may consider further legal options, including a potential appeal to the Wisconsin Supreme Court. However, the court's clear stance on sovereign immunity and the limitations of indemnification claims suggest that an appeal may face significant challenges. No related cases are currently pending that would directly affect this ruling.
Read Next
Wisconsin Court Affirms Dismissal of Mueller's Claims
Wisconsin Court Affirms Trespass Ruling Against Dixon
Wisconsin Appeals Court Upholds Judgment Modification
Court rules on lease dispute between Northern Biomedical and NBR
Michigan Court affirms ruling on VanScoyoc Trust property transfer
Daily Journal Names Mary Alexander Among California’s Top Plaintiff Lawyers for 2026










