The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has ruled on a significant zoning case involving a proposed bed-and-breakfast (B&B) in East Bradford Township. The court's decision, issued on November 18, 2026, affects property owners and local zoning regulations across the state. At the heart of the case was whether a zoning hearing board could grant a use variance based on the argument that the variance sought was minor, or 'de minimis.'
The ruling clarifies the standards for granting use variances in Pennsylvania, emphasizing that such variances cannot be considered de minimis. This decision may have implications for future zoning applications and property development in the state.
Background
The case involves John Marshall and Dara Gans Marshall, who own approximately eleven acres of property in East Bradford Township, Chester County. The property includes a historic home known as the Paxson House, a tenant house previously used as a veterinary clinic, and a barn. The Marshalls sought to operate a B&B using the Paxson House as their residence and the tenant house for guest accommodations.
However, the East Bradford Township Zoning Ordinance stipulates that only owner-occupied Class I historic resources are eligible for B&B use. The Marshalls applied for a use variance in December 2017 to allow them to use the tenant house for guest rooms while keeping the Paxson House for their family. The local zoning hearing board initially granted their application, stating that the request was reasonable given the unique circumstances of the property.
However, neighboring property owners Dorothy and Daniel Soland, along with the East Bradford Township Board of Supervisors, appealed the decision. The trial court reversed the zoning board's ruling, stating that the Marshalls did not demonstrate the necessary hardship to warrant a variance. The Marshalls then appealed to the Commonwealth Court, which reinstated the zoning board's decision, leading to further appeals to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court.
The Ruling
The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ultimately ruled that a use variance cannot be considered de minimis. Chief Justice Debra Todd, writing for the court, stated, "we hold that a use variance cannot be considered de minimis, and, thus, that the use variance granted in the instant case was improper." This ruling reverses the Commonwealth Court's decision that had allowed for the de minimis doctrine to apply to use variances.
The court's opinion emphasized that the requirements for obtaining a variance are stringent and that the burden of proof lies with the applicant. The court clarified that a use variance is distinct from a dimensional variance, as it involves a proposal to use the property in a manner that is outside the zoning regulations. The court noted that the Marshalls did not meet the necessary criteria for a use variance under the Pennsylvania Municipalities Planning Code.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for property owners and zoning boards across Pennsylvania. It establishes that use variances cannot be granted based on the argument that they are minor deviations from zoning regulations. This decision may lead to stricter enforcement of zoning laws and could deter property owners from seeking variances without substantial justification.
The ruling also reinforces the principle that zoning boards must carefully consider the potential impact of any variance on the surrounding community and adhere to the established criteria for granting such requests. This could result in fewer successful applications for use variances in the future, as property owners will need to demonstrate a clear and compelling need for any deviations from zoning regulations.
What's Next
The decision by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court is final and cannot be appealed. However, it may influence future cases involving zoning variances and could prompt local governments to review and potentially amend their zoning ordinances in response to the ruling. As municipalities assess their regulations, property owners may need to adapt their plans accordingly.
Read Next
Pennsylvania court vacates contempt conviction of Kyle Goodman
Pennsylvania court affirms murder conviction of Aaron Johnson
Pennsylvania Court Upholds Guardian Appointment for P.H.
Michigan Court affirms ruling on VanScoyoc Trust property transfer
Daily Journal Names Mary Alexander Among California’s Top Plaintiff Lawyers for 2026
Texas Court Orders Venue Change in Election Contest Case










