The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled on November 18, 2026, that a zoning hearing board cannot grant a use variance based on the argument that the variance is de minimis. This decision affects property owners in East Bradford Township who sought to operate a bed-and-breakfast (B&B) on their property. The ruling reverses a previous decision by the Commonwealth Court that had reinstated the zoning board's approval of the variance.

This case arose from a dispute involving John and Dara Gans Marshall, who own approximately eleven acres of property in East Bradford Township. They wanted to operate a B&B using their historic Paxson House as their residence and the Tenant House, which previously served as a veterinary clinic, for guest quarters. However, the East Bradford Township Zoning Ordinance only allows B&Bs in owner-occupied Class I historic resources, which the Tenant House is not. The Marshalls applied for a use variance to allow their plans.

The East Bradford Township Zoning Hearing Board (ZHB) initially granted the Marshalls' application in March 2018, arguing that the variance was reasonable and in line with the intent of preserving historic structures. However, neighboring property owners Dorothy and Daniel Soland, along with the East Bradford Township Board of Supervisors, appealed the decision. The trial court reversed the ZHB's ruling, stating that the Marshalls had not demonstrated the necessary hardship required for a variance.

The Marshalls then appealed to the Commonwealth Court, which ruled in their favor, stating that the de minimis doctrine could apply to use variances. The court noted that the variance requested was more technical than substantial and would not adversely affect the public interest. This decision was met with dissent from Judge Ellen Ceisler, who agreed that the de minimis doctrine could apply but disagreed with its application in this case.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court, led by Chief Justice Debra Todd, reviewed the case and concluded that the Commonwealth Court erred in allowing the de minimis doctrine to apply to use variances. The court ruled, "a use variance cannot be considered de minimis, and, thus, that the use variance granted in the instant case was improper." The court emphasized that the requirements for a variance are significant and that the de minimis doctrine should not be extended to use variances.

This ruling clarifies that variances must meet strict criteria, including demonstrating unnecessary hardship due to unique physical circumstances of the property. The court stated that the burden of proof lies with the party seeking the variance, and the failure to meet these requirements constitutes an error of law.

The impact of this ruling is significant for property owners in Pennsylvania, particularly those seeking to operate businesses that may not conform to existing zoning regulations. The court's decision reinforces the importance of adhering to zoning laws and the necessity of proving hardship for variances. This could potentially limit the number of use variances granted in the future, as applicants will need to meet higher standards to obtain approval.

Looking ahead, the decision can be appealed, but it is unclear if further legal action will be pursued. The case highlights ongoing tensions between property rights and zoning regulations, a topic that continues to be relevant in many communities across Pennsylvania.