The California Court of Appeal has dismissed an appeal filed by Jerry Pollard, who sought relief under the California Racial Justice Act (RJA) of 2020. The court ruled that the order from the trial court was nonappealable, meaning Pollard cannot pursue his claims regarding racial discrimination in his conviction. This decision affects Pollard, who has been incarcerated since 1986, and highlights the complexities surrounding the application of the RJA.
Pollard's case began with a first-degree murder conviction in 1986, which was later reduced to second-degree murder after a series of appeals. His recent attempts to seek relief under the RJA included allegations of racial bias during his trial and sentencing. The court's dismissal of his appeal raises questions about the effectiveness of the RJA in addressing past injustices.
Background
Jerry Pollard was convicted of first-degree murder in 1986, with enhancements for personal use of a firearm. After a series of appeals, his conviction was reduced to second-degree murder. Pollard filed a petition for writ of habeas corpus in 1989, which was denied, and he was resentenced to 22 years to life in prison. Since then, he has sought various forms of relief, including under the RJA, which was enacted to address racial discrimination in the criminal justice system.
The RJA allows defendants to seek relief if they can prove that their conviction or sentence was influenced by racial bias. Pollard's claims included allegations that his arrest was racially motivated, that his trial counsel exhibited racial animus, and that he was treated more harshly than non-Black defendants. His attempts to file a motion for relief under the RJA and request for postjudgment discovery were denied by the trial court, leading to his appeal.
The Ruling
The California Court of Appeal ruled that Pollard's appeal was nonappealable. The court stated, "The order is nonappealable and dismiss the appeal." This ruling was based on the fact that the trial court had no jurisdiction to consider the RJA motion, as Pollard's conviction had become final in 1989 and there were no ongoing criminal proceedings. The court emphasized that the RJA is intended for use during active criminal proceedings, not for postjudgment claims.
The judges on the panel included Acting Presiding Justice Fujisaki, Justice Petrou, and Justice RodrÃguez. They noted that Pollard could file new motions under the RJA in light of recent legislative changes, but the current appeal could not proceed.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for Pollard and others similarly situated. It underscores the challenges faced by individuals seeking to utilize the RJA after their convictions have become final. The court's decision highlights the need for clarity on how the RJA can be applied, particularly for those who have already exhausted their appeals.
Pollard's case also raises broader questions about racial justice in the criminal justice system. As the RJA is still relatively new, its application and effectiveness in providing relief for past injustices remain uncertain. The dismissal of Pollard's appeal may deter others from seeking similar relief, as it illustrates the difficulties in navigating the legal system.
What's Next
Pollard may still pursue new motions under the RJA, as the court's dismissal was without prejudice. This means he can file a new request based on the updated provisions of the law. However, the dismissal of his appeal indicates that navigating the complexities of the RJA will continue to be a challenge for him and others in similar situations.
Read Next
Court dismisses appeal in domestic violence restraining order
Oregon court upholds sexual abuse protective order appeal
Seventh Circuit Court Reverses Dismissal of Illinois Law Case
Court upholds ruling against Fishman in disability case
Court affirms ruling in disability discrimination case
Court affirms dismissal of privacy claim against PitchBook










