The Pennsylvania Supreme Court recently ruled on a significant zoning case involving the use of variances. The court's decision affects property owners and zoning boards across the state, clarifying the standards for granting use variances in zoning cases. The ruling specifically addressed whether a zoning hearing board could grant a use variance based on the idea that the variance sought is de minimis, meaning minor or insignificant.
This case originated from a dispute between the Marshalls, who own property in East Bradford Township, and neighboring property owners, the Solands, along with the East Bradford Township Board of Supervisors. The Marshalls sought to operate a bed-and-breakfast (B&B) on their property, which includes a historic home and other structures. However, the East Bradford Township Zoning Ordinance restricts B&B operations to owner-occupied Class I historic resources, which the Marshalls argued their property did not fully comply with.
The Marshalls applied for a use variance to allow them to use a different structure on their property, the Tenant House, for guest accommodations while keeping their main residence, the Paxson House, as their private home. Initially, the East Bradford Township Zoning Hearing Board granted their application, stating that the variance was reasonable and in keeping with the intent of preserving historic structures. However, the Solands and the Township Board appealed this decision, leading to a series of court rulings.
The trial court reversed the Zoning Hearing Board's decision, stating that the Marshalls did not demonstrate an unnecessary hardship that would justify the variance. The court emphasized that the Marshalls' situation was self-imposed and that the requested variance could not be considered de minimis. The Marshalls then appealed to the Commonwealth Court, which ruled in their favor, stating that the de minimis doctrine could apply to use variances.
The case eventually reached the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, which ruled on November 18, 2026. Chief Justice Debra Todd, writing for the court, stated, "We hold that a use variance cannot be considered de minimis, and, thus, that the use variance granted in the instant case was improper." This ruling reversed the Commonwealth Court's decision and reinstated the trial court's ruling against the Marshalls.
The court's opinion clarified that while landowners have rights to use their property, these rights are subject to reasonable restrictions imposed by zoning ordinances. The court emphasized that a use variance is different from a dimensional variance, as it allows for a use that is entirely outside the zoning regulations. The requirements for obtaining a variance are strict, and the burden of proof rests on the applicant.
This ruling is significant for property owners and zoning boards in Pennsylvania. It establishes that use variances cannot be granted based on the notion of being de minimis, which could have allowed for more leniency in zoning regulations. The decision reinforces the need for applicants to meet the stringent requirements set forth in the Pennsylvania Municipalities Planning Code and local ordinances.
Going forward, this ruling may impact how zoning boards evaluate applications for use variances. It could lead to more rigorous scrutiny of variance requests and limit the ability of property owners to deviate from established zoning regulations. This decision may also discourage future attempts to apply the de minimis doctrine in cases involving use variances, as the court has made it clear that such variances must meet the established criteria.
As for the Marshalls, the ruling means they will not be able to operate their proposed bed-and-breakfast as planned, as the court's decision reinstates the restrictions imposed by the East Bradford Township Zoning Ordinance. The case underscores the complexities involved in zoning laws and the importance of adhering to local regulations.
Details were not available in the court filing regarding potential next steps for the Marshalls or whether they plan to appeal the ruling further. However, the decision sets a clear precedent regarding the application of use variances in Pennsylvania.
Read Next
Pennsylvania court vacates contempt conviction of Kyle Goodman
Pennsylvania court affirms murder conviction of Aaron Johnson
Pennsylvania Court Upholds Guardian Appointment for P.H.
Michigan Court affirms ruling on VanScoyoc Trust property transfer
Daily Journal Names Mary Alexander Among California’s Top Plaintiff Lawyers for 2026
Texas Court Orders Venue Change in Election Contest Case










