The Pennsylvania Supreme Court recently ruled against the East Bradford Township Zoning Hearing Board's decision to grant a use variance for a bed-and-breakfast (B&B) on a historic property. This ruling impacts the Marshalls, who sought to operate a B&B on their property, and sets a precedent regarding the application of zoning laws in Pennsylvania.

The case, titled Soland, D. v. ZHB E. Bradford Twp, was argued on March 11, 2026, and the court's decision was issued on November 18, 2026. The ruling is significant because it clarifies the standards for granting use variances in Pennsylvania, particularly whether such variances can be considered de minimis, or minor.

Background

The parties involved in this case include John Marshall and Dara Gans Marshall, who own approximately eleven acres in East Bradford Township, Chester County. Their property contains several structures, including the Paxson House, a Class I historic resource, and the Tenant House, a Class II historic resource. The Marshalls applied for a use variance to operate a B&B, intending to use the Tenant House for guest accommodations while living in the Paxson House.

According to the East Bradford Township Zoning Ordinance, only owner-occupied Class I historic resources are eligible for B&B use. The Marshalls filed their application in December 2017, arguing that the Paxson House was not large enough to accommodate their family and the required minimum number of guest rooms. The Zoning Hearing Board (ZHB) granted their application in March 2018, citing the unique circumstances of the property and the intent to preserve historic structures.

However, neighboring property owners Dorothy and Daniel Soland, along with the East Bradford Township Board of Supervisors, appealed the ZHB's decision. The trial court reversed the ZHB's decision, stating that the Marshalls did not demonstrate the necessary hardship to warrant a variance. The Marshalls then appealed to the Commonwealth Court, which ruled in their favor, reinstating the ZHB's decision.

The Ruling

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ultimately reversed the Commonwealth Court's decision. Chief Justice Debra Todd, writing for the court, stated, "A use variance cannot be considered de minimis, and thus, the use variance granted in the instant case was improper." The court emphasized that variances are meant to address significant deviations from zoning regulations, and the standards for granting such variances must be strictly adhered to.

The court highlighted the importance of maintaining the integrity of zoning ordinances, stating that the de minimis doctrine, which allows for minor deviations, should not apply to use variances. This ruling reinforces the idea that land use decisions must consider the broader implications on public interest and zoning policy.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for property owners and local governments in Pennsylvania. It clarifies that use variances cannot be granted based on the notion that the requested change is minor. Property owners seeking variances must meet the established criteria, demonstrating unnecessary hardship and ensuring that the proposed use aligns with zoning regulations.

The decision may deter future applications for use variances by setting a higher standard for approval. Local zoning boards will need to carefully evaluate requests to ensure compliance with the law, potentially reducing the number of variances granted in similar cases.

What's Next

The Marshalls may seek to appeal the decision, but the court's ruling is a significant setback for their plans to operate a B&B. There are no related cases pending that directly address this issue, but the ruling may influence how future zoning variance applications are handled throughout Pennsylvania.