A New York appellate court has upheld a decision regarding a workers' compensation claim made by Carlos Eusebio-Brito, an Uber driver who alleged he sustained injuries in a motor vehicle accident. The court's ruling, issued on November 19, 2026, confirmed the Workers' Compensation Board's earlier findings that precluded Eusebio-Brito's evidence regarding his claim for a schedule loss of use (SLU) of his right arm. This decision is significant as it affects how workers' compensation claims are evaluated, particularly in cases involving independent medical examinations.

The case, officially titled Matter of Eusebio-Brito v. New York Black Car Operators, was assigned docket number CV-25-0974. It stemmed from Eusebio-Brito's claim that he suffered work-related injuries in March 2022 due to a motor vehicle accident. The injuries he reported included damage to his lower back, neck, and right shoulder. Following the accident, he sought workers' compensation benefits to cover his medical expenses and lost wages.

The dispute arose when different medical professionals evaluated Eusebio-Brito's condition. In March 2024, Dr. Robert Hecht, an orthopedic surgeon, examined Eusebio-Brito and filed a report indicating that the injury to his right shoulder had reached maximum medical improvement and that he had sustained a 15% SLU of the right arm. However, another orthopedic surgeon, Dr. Richard Semble, conducted an independent medical examination in June 2024 and concluded that Eusebio-Brito had no impairment of the cervical or lumbar spine and a 0% SLU of the right arm.

The Workers' Compensation Law Judge (WCLJ) reviewed the evidence and determined that Hecht's report should be excluded because it did not comply with the requirements set forth in Workers' Compensation Law § 137. The WCLJ credited Semble's findings over Hecht's, leading to the Workers' Compensation Board affirming the WCLJ's decision. Eusebio-Brito subsequently appealed the Board's ruling.

The court ruled in favor of the Workers' Compensation Board, affirming their decision to exclude Hecht's report. The judges noted, “An attending physician or other attending practitioner is defined as the provider or practitioner who has primary responsibility for treating the claimant for the injury or illness.” The court found that Hecht acted as an independent medical examiner during his final evaluation of Eusebio-Brito, which justified the exclusion of his report.

The judges involved in this ruling included Aarons, J.P., Pritzker, Reynolds Fitzgerald, Ceresia, and Mackey. They collectively agreed that substantial evidence supported the Board's determination regarding the classification of Hecht's examination and the exclusion of his report.

The court's decision has implications for future workers' compensation claims, particularly those involving independent medical examinations. By affirming the Board's ruling, the court reinforced the importance of compliance with statutory and regulatory requirements for medical evaluations in workers' compensation cases. This ruling could set a precedent for how similar cases are handled in the future, emphasizing the need for proper documentation and adherence to legal standards.

Going forward, this ruling may affect not only Eusebio-Brito but also other workers who file claims for compensation after workplace injuries. The decision highlights the significance of having clear and compliant medical evaluations to support claims for benefits. It serves as a reminder to claimants that the qualifications and roles of medical examiners can significantly impact the outcome of their cases.

As for what’s next, it is unclear if Eusebio-Brito will seek further appeals. The court's decision is final unless contested through higher courts. There are no related cases pending that were mentioned in the court filing.