A New York appellate court has ruled against a worker's request for shoulder surgery, stating that the need for the procedure was not causally related to a prior work injury. This decision affects Erich Schindlar, who has been seeking authorization for surgery on his right shoulder after suffering injuries in a workplace accident in 2004. The ruling highlights the challenges workers face when trying to prove that subsequent medical issues are linked to earlier injuries.
The case, known as Matter of Schindlar v. Incorporated Village of Sands Point, was decided by the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York on November 19, 2026. The court's decision is significant for workers' compensation claims, particularly in cases where a long time has passed between the original injury and a request for additional medical treatment.
Background
Erich Schindlar, the appellant in this case, suffered work-related injuries in May 2004, which included damage to his neck, back, right shoulder, and right wrist. After the incident, Schindlar returned to full-time work and was denied lost wages benefits because he was not disabled for more than seven days. Medical evaluations following the injury indicated that he had a full range of motion in his shoulder and that his right shoulder contusion had resolved.
In September 2021, Schindlar's orthopedic surgeon, Brian Neri, requested authorization for surgery based on an MRI that revealed a torn rotator cuff. However, the employer's workers' compensation carrier denied this request, arguing that the rotator cuff tear was not related to the 2004 accident. Following this, a Workers' Compensation Law Judge ruled that Schindlar had not shown a causal relationship between the tear and the original injury, leading to a denial of surgery authorization.
In May 2022, another orthopedic surgeon, Justin Mirza, made a similar request for surgery authorization, which was again denied. The Workers' Compensation Board upheld the denial, prompting Schindlar to appeal the decision.
The Ruling
The court ruled that Schindlar did not meet the burden of proving that his need for right shoulder surgery was causally related to the 2004 workplace injury. The judges noted, "Claimant bears the burden of establishing a causal relationship when 'seek[ing] surgical authorization for a procedure allegedly attributable to an established work-related injury.'" The court emphasized that the Workers' Compensation Board is empowered to determine factual issues regarding causation based on the record, and its findings will not be disturbed if supported by substantial evidence.
The court also pointed out that the medical opinions presented by Schindlar's doctors were insufficient to establish a causal link. Specifically, the court stated, "Although the Board can certainly rely upon a medical opinion as to causation even if it is not absolute or certain, it is also free to disregard the medical evidence that it finds unconvincing β including an opinion that is unsupported and speculative." The decision was affirmed without costs, indicating that Schindlar would not receive reimbursement for the legal expenses incurred during the appeal.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for workers seeking medical treatment related to past injuries. It underscores the importance of establishing a clear causal connection between a current medical issue and a previous work-related injury. The decision may deter future claims where a significant time gap exists between the initial injury and subsequent medical requests, as workers must provide compelling evidence to support their claims.
The ruling may also influence how medical professionals approach evaluations for work-related injuries. Doctors may need to be more diligent in reviewing a patient's medical history and providing detailed justifications for their opinions on causation. This case serves as a reminder that the burden of proof lies with the claimant, and without strong evidence, requests for further treatment may be denied.
What's Next
Schindlar can potentially appeal this decision to a higher court, but details on whether he plans to do so were not available in the court filing. There may also be related cases pending that could further clarify the standards for establishing causation in workers' compensation claims.
Read Next
Court modifies ruling on attorneys' fees in Galleria case
Court orders New York to disclose certain public records
Court upholds JPMorgan Chase's trust accounting in Rockefeller case
New York Court upholds dismissal of vicarious liability case
Court orders review of employment records in injury case
Illinois Court Upholds Termination of Police Disability Benefits









