New York attorney Marc Allan Fernich has received a public censure from the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York following an altercation during a protest. The incident, which took place on September 29, 2025, involved Fernich engaging in aggressive behavior and making inflammatory remarks towards demonstrators. This ruling affects Fernich's professional standing and serves as a reminder of the standards expected from attorneys in their conduct.
The Attorney Grievance Committee (AGC) for the First Judicial Department initiated disciplinary proceedings against Fernich, alleging that his actions violated the Rules of Professional Misconduct. The case, identified by Motion No. 2026-04998 and Case No. 2026-03249, highlights the importance of maintaining professionalism, even outside the courtroom.
Background
Marc Allan Fernich, who has been practicing law since 1992, found himself at the center of controversy after an incident at a demonstration supporting Palestine outside the federal courthouse in New York City. The AGC filed charges against him, claiming that his behavior during the protest reflected poorly on his fitness as a lawyer. The AGC's motion for discipline by consent sought a public censure, which Fernich agreed to.
The altercation occurred as Fernich attempted to navigate through a group of demonstrators. Video footage captured him making physical contact with several individuals and using derogatory language. The AGC's notice and petition of charges detailed the nature of Fernich's remarks, which included antisemitic comments and threats. The incident raised serious concerns about his conduct, prompting the AGC to take action.
The Ruling
On November 19, 2026, the court ruled in favor of the AGC's motion for discipline by consent. The court acknowledged the severity of Fernich's actions but also considered mitigating factors. The ruling stated, "Respondent's use of antisemitic and threatening language, together with his physical aggression towards demonstrators, warrants public discipline." The court emphasized that while Fernich's behavior was unacceptable, there were circumstances that warranted a lesser sanction.
The ruling noted that Fernich had no prior disciplinary history and that the incident was isolated and unrelated to his professional duties. The court also took into account his medical issues at the time, including recovery from surgery and ongoing psychiatric treatment. The ruling concluded by granting the motion for public censure and denying the AGC’s petition of charges as moot.
Impact
This ruling serves as a significant reminder of the standards expected from attorneys in New York. Public censure reflects the profession's condemnation of Fernich's conduct while acknowledging the mitigating factors, such as his cooperation with the investigation and his lack of prior disciplinary issues. The decision reinforces the notion that attorneys must maintain professionalism in all situations, including public demonstrations.
Fernich's case may have broader implications for how similar incidents are handled in the future. It underscores the importance of accountability in the legal profession, especially when an attorney's behavior raises questions about their fitness to practice law. The ruling may influence how disciplinary actions are approached in cases involving personal conduct outside of legal practice.
What's Next
Fernich's public censure is a final ruling in this matter, but it is possible for him to appeal the decision. However, details about any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. There are no related cases pending at this time.
Read Next
Court orders New York to disclose certain public records
Court upholds JPMorgan Chase's trust accounting in Rockefeller case
Court dismisses appeal in Cohen v. 458 Grand Broadway case
Court upholds domestic violence protection order renewal
Tennessee Court Upholds Defamation Verdict in Business Dispute
Court dismisses Pollard's appeal over racial justice claims










