The New York Court of Appeals has ruled in a case involving podiatric malpractice, affirming a lower court's decision that allows a lawsuit against a podiatrist to proceed. This ruling, made on November 19, 2026, affects healthcare professionals who may seek immunity under emergency laws during health crises, such as the COVID-19 pandemic.
The case, Zain v. Ernest L. Isaacson, DPM, P.C. (Docket No. 96), centers around Robert Zain, who is the plaintiff, and Ernest L. Isaacson, DPM, P.C., along with other defendants. The court's decision is significant as it clarifies the scope of immunity provided to healthcare professionals under the Emergency or Disaster Treatment Protection Act (EDTPA) during the pandemic.
In this case, Zain alleged that he suffered harm due to malpractice by the defendants during treatments he received in April 2020. The defendants sought to dismiss the lawsuit, claiming they were immune from liability under the EDTPA, which was enacted to protect healthcare providers during emergencies. However, the court found that the defendants did not meet the criteria to qualify for this immunity.
The dispute arose when the defendants argued that they were providing healthcare services under the authority of COVID-19 emergency rules. However, the court determined that podiatrists were not included in the list of healthcare professionals eligible for immunity under the relevant public health law. The court noted, "Defendants failed to establish as a matter of law that they are entitled to immunity pursuant to the Emergency or Disaster Treatment Protection Act (EDTPA) in effect at the relevant time."
The ruling emphasized that the defendants did not demonstrate that their treatment of Zain fell within the scope of authority permitted by COVID-19 emergency rules. Specifically, the court pointed out that the defendants did not provide evidence that their actions complied with the necessary regulations during the pandemic.
The court's decision was unanimous, with Chief Judge Wilson and Judges Rivera, Garcia, Singas, Cannataro, Troutman, and Halligan all concurring. The court affirmed the order of the Appellate Division, which had previously denied the defendants' motion to dismiss the complaint.
This ruling carries significant implications for healthcare providers, particularly in how they navigate legal protections during emergencies. The court's decision clarifies that simply providing healthcare services during a pandemic does not automatically grant immunity from malpractice claims. This means that healthcare professionals must ensure they are operating within the legal frameworks established during emergency situations.
Going forward, this ruling may impact how podiatrists and other healthcare providers approach their practice during emergencies. They will need to be more cautious and ensure compliance with all relevant laws and regulations to avoid potential liability for malpractice. This case may also encourage more patients to pursue claims against healthcare providers if they believe they have been harmed, especially during periods of crisis.
Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether the defendants plan to appeal the ruling. However, the decision sets a precedent that could influence future cases involving healthcare malpractice claims during emergencies. As the legal landscape continues to evolve, healthcare providers will need to stay informed about their rights and responsibilities under the law.
In summary, the New York Court of Appeals has made a significant ruling in Zain v. Ernest L. Isaacson, DPM, P.C., affirming the lower court's decision and clarifying the limitations of immunity for healthcare providers during emergencies. This case highlights the importance of adhering to legal standards in the provision of medical care, especially in challenging circumstances like a pandemic.














