The Ohio Court of Appeals has upheld a domestic violence protection order against Olayinka Hamed Olalekan, affirming the lower court's decision and jurisdiction in the case. This ruling affects the lives of both Olalekan and Adesola Soyele, the petitioner, by maintaining the protection order originally issued in 2026. The court's decision is significant in clarifying the legal standards for personal jurisdiction in domestic violence cases.
The case, Soyele v. Olalekan, was filed under docket number 26 CAF 06 0063. It centers around the relationship between Soyele and Olalekan, which began while both were still married to other people. Their relationship, which began in Illinois in 2022, was marked by volatility and ended in 2024. After the relationship ended, Soyele relocated to Columbus, Ohio, but continued to receive threatening messages that she believed were from Olalekan, leading her to seek legal protection.
Following a series of troubling encounters and communications, Soyele filed a petition for a domestic violence civil protection order against Olalekan on April 8, 2025. Initially, the court dismissed her petition due to a lack of evidence that they were family or household members, which is a requirement under Ohio law. However, later that same day, Soyele filed for a dating violence civil protection order, which was granted after a second hearing.
The case progressed to a full hearing on January 13, 2026, where both parties presented their arguments. The magistrate recommended a five-year civil protection order against Olalekan, which the trial court adopted. Olalekan subsequently filed objections to this decision, prompting the appeal that led to the recent ruling.
The court ruled on several key points raised by Olalekan in his appeal. First, it found that the trial court had proper jurisdiction over him, despite his residence in Illinois. The court explained, "It should be foreseeable to one who makes threatening communications that he may be haled into the jurisdiction to answer a petition seeking protection against him." This statement underscores the importance of maintaining legal accountability for actions that cross state lines, especially in cases involving threats and domestic violence.
Moreover, the court addressed Olalekan's claims regarding due process, stating that he waived his rights by participating in the hearings without contesting jurisdiction at the time. The judges noted that personal jurisdiction can be established if a defendant has sufficient contacts with the state where the case is filed. In this instance, the court found that Olalekan's communications with Soyele, which included threats made after she moved to Ohio, satisfied the requirements for jurisdiction.
Additionally, the court ruled against Olalekan's argument that the second petition for a dating violence protection order was barred by res judicata, which prevents the same issue from being tried again once it has been judged. The court determined that the two petitions were not identical in nature, as the first was dismissed without prejudice and did not address the specific claims of dating violence.
Finally, the court rejected Olalekan's assertion that the trial court improperly treated the transcript deadline as absolute. The judges noted that the trial court had the discretion to consider the objections raised by Olalekan, even without the late transcript, and ultimately found that his objections lacked merit.
The ruling has significant implications for future domestic violence cases in Ohio, particularly those involving parties from different states. It reinforces the principle that individuals can be held accountable for their actions, regardless of their residence, if their conduct affects someone in another state. This case also highlights the importance of timely legal action and the potential consequences of failing to contest jurisdiction during proceedings.
Looking ahead, Olalekan has the option to appeal the decision to a higher court, although details regarding any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. The outcome of this case may influence similar cases involving domestic violence and jurisdictional issues in Ohio and beyond.
Read Next
Ohio court affirms civil stalking protection order in family case
Ohio court reverses sentence for community control violation
Ohio Court of Appeals dismisses appeal in Keith divorce case
California Court of Appeal rules on mental competency case
Ninth Circuit denies injunction in Vitalich v. 1sharpe Capital
Court upholds dismissal of condo association's insurance claim










