The Ohio Court of Appeals recently upheld a civil stalking protection order (CSPO) against A.H., a grandmother accused of causing mental distress to her daughter-in-law, D.G., and her child. This decision, issued on November 19, 2026, is significant as it reinforces the importance of protecting individuals from perceived threats within family dynamics.
The case arose when D.G. filed a petition for a CSPO against A.H. in September 2025, following a series of altercations between them. The court's ruling highlights the complexities of family relationships and the legal measures available to protect individuals from perceived threats.
Background
D.G. is the mother of a minor child, and A.H. is the child's paternal grandmother. The conflict began when D.G. sought a CSPO against A.H., citing two specific incidents that caused her mental distress. The first incident occurred on September 3, 2025, when A.H. allegedly came to D.G.'s home wielding a bat, leading to a physical altercation. The second incident took place two weeks later, on September 17, when A.H. reportedly followed D.G. in her vehicle in a reckless manner, which D.G. claimed made her feel unsafe.
A magistrate initially granted an ex parte CSPO, which led to a full hearing where both parties testified. The magistrate found D.G.'s testimony to be more credible than A.H.'s, leading to the decision to grant the CSPO for three years, protecting both D.G. and her child. A.H. later filed objections to the magistrate's decision, challenging the credibility findings and the application of the stalking law.
The Ruling
The Ohio Court of Appeals, led by Judge Kathleen Ann Keough, affirmed the trial court's decision to grant the CSPO. The court noted that A.H. raised several objections, including claims that the evidence did not support a finding of menacing by stalking under Ohio law. However, the court emphasized that A.H. did not provide a transcript of the hearing, which limited the court's ability to review the factual findings made by the magistrate.
The court ruled, "Absent a transcript to review the testimony and evidence regarding the 'pattern-of-conduct' finding and the subsequent finding that A.H.'s conduct rose to the level of knowingly causing D.G. to believe A.H. would cause physical harm or mental distress, we must presume regularity of the trial court proceedings and accept that the facts were correctly interpreted."
The court also addressed A.H.'s concerns about the inclusion of the minor child as a protected person and the three-year duration of the CSPO. The court found no error in the trial court's decision and noted that A.H. failed to demonstrate why the three-year duration was excessive.
Impact
This ruling has important implications for similar cases involving family disputes and stalking allegations. It underscores the legal protections available to individuals who feel threatened, even within familial relationships. The decision also highlights the necessity of proper documentation, such as transcripts, when appealing a court's ruling. Without this documentation, a party may struggle to challenge the factual findings of the lower court.
Furthermore, the court's affirmation of the CSPO sets a precedent that emphasizes the seriousness of mental distress claims in the context of stalking. It serves as a reminder that the courts take allegations of threatening behavior seriously, particularly when they involve children.
What's Next
A.H. can potentially seek further legal remedies, but the likelihood of a successful appeal appears limited due to her failure to provide necessary documentation. There are no related cases pending in this matter at the moment. The ruling reinforces the need for individuals involved in similar disputes to be aware of their legal rights and the importance of following proper legal procedures.
Read Next
Ohio court reverses sentence for community control violation
Ohio Court of Appeals dismisses appeal in Keith divorce case
Ohio court affirms dismissal of breach of contract case
Hawaii Supreme Court denies petition for extraordinary writ
Court affirms dismissal of Marc Stephens' claims against CareOne
California Court rules against employer's arbitration clause










