In a recent ruling, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit affirmed the dismissal of claims made by Marc A. Stephens against CareOne Management LLC and others. This decision, filed on November 19, 2026, affects Stephens, who has been a caretaker for his mother, Viola, and raises important questions about the legal responsibilities of care facilities and law enforcement in domestic situations.
The case, identified by docket number 25-3168, originated from a series of events involving a 911 call made by Stephens' sister, which led to police intervention and subsequent allegations against Stephens regarding his care for his mother. The court's ruling highlights the complexities of due process claims and the legal definitions of state action.
Background
Marc A. Stephens has served as the caretaker for his mother, Viola, since 2000. He holds a durable power of attorney that includes rights over her home located at 271 Rosemont Place in Englewood, New Jersey. The dispute began when, on December 29, 2021, his sister, Kim, called the police, alleging that Stephens was harassing and physically abusing their mother. This prompted Officer Barrett and another officer to respond to the call.
Initially hesitant to allow the officers entry without a warrant, Stephens eventually permitted them to enter and check on Viola. Officer Barrett concluded that Viola appeared unharmed but later, during questioning, Viola contradicted Stephens’ claim that no one else was in the house, prompting the officers to search the second floor. No one was found, but this incident set the stage for a series of legal claims that would follow.
In January 2022, after Viola was admitted to CareOne's rehabilitation facility, Stephens alleged that both CareOne and the Englewood police made false statements about his care for Viola. He claimed these statements led to the facility's refusal to discharge her back to his care, asserting that they endangered her welfare. Consequently, Stephens filed a lawsuit in the District Court, raising claims under both state and federal law.
The Ruling
The Third Circuit Court reviewed the District Court's decisions, which included dismissing some of Stephens' claims and granting summary judgment on the remaining federal claim. The court found that Stephens failed to establish a due process claim against the CareOne Defendants, stating, "neither CareOne, a private rehabilitation center, nor Iacolina, a private individual, is a state actor." This ruling indicates that private entities are not subject to the same constitutional obligations as state actors.
The court also noted that Stephens did not provide sufficient evidence to support his claim of conspiracy between the CareOne and Englewood Defendants. The opinion stated, "Stephens failed to allege 'facts regarding any agreement between the Defendants sufficient to support an inference of conspiracy.'" Furthermore, the court upheld the District Court's decision to grant summary judgment on Stephens' Fourth Amendment claim, concluding that the police's warrantless entry was justified under the exigent circumstances exception.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for individuals involved in similar disputes, particularly regarding the responsibilities of care facilities and the authority of law enforcement during domestic incidents. The court's affirmation of the lower court's ruling reinforces the idea that private entities like CareOne are not considered state actors and thus do not have the same obligations under the Constitution. This could limit the ability of individuals to hold such facilities accountable through federal claims.
Moreover, the decision clarifies the standards for warrantless entries by law enforcement, emphasizing that officers can act without a warrant when there is a reasonable belief that someone inside a home is in danger. This aspect of the ruling may influence future cases involving police responses to domestic violence or welfare checks.
What's Next
While the Third Circuit has upheld the dismissal of Stephens' claims, he may still seek further legal avenues, including potential appeals to the U.S. Supreme Court. However, the court's ruling provides a strong precedent that may limit the success of such appeals. Details regarding any related cases or further actions by Stephens were not available in the court filing.
Read Next
Court denies Morales-Medina's appeal against removal orders
Court denies Rivera-Bonilla's immigration appeal in BIA case
Court affirms sentence for Hector Cruz Ciprian's violations
California Court rules against employer's arbitration clause
Ninth Circuit affirms denial of Playstudios' arbitration request
Court dismisses Haywood's petition against MSPB for noncompliance










