The Third Circuit Court of Appeals has affirmed the conviction of Thomas Waters, a federal inmate, for assaulting three federal corrections officers during an altercation at the prison. The court ruled on November 19, 2026, following an appeal by Waters who challenged both his conviction and the sentence imposed by the lower court. This case is significant as it addresses the legal standards surrounding inmate conduct and the application of sentencing enhancements in relation to the use of weapons and obstruction of justice.

Waters was convicted on three counts of assaulting federal corrections officers under 18 U.S.C. § 111(a)(1) and (b). The incident occurred in January 2023 when Waters was involved in a confrontation with Officer James Grizzanti, who noticed Waters wearing conflicting religious items that violated prison policy. The altercation escalated, resulting in injuries to both Waters and the officers involved. This case highlights the challenges faced by law enforcement in managing inmate behavior and the legal ramifications of such confrontations.

The appeal reached the Third Circuit after Waters was sentenced to a term that included enhancements for using a dangerous weapon and for obstruction of justice. Waters argued that the District Court had violated his Sixth Amendment rights by not allowing him to represent himself and by improperly applying these enhancements during sentencing.

Background

Thomas Waters was serving time as a federal inmate when he became involved in a violent confrontation with corrections officers at the prison. The altercation began when Officer Grizzanti noticed Waters wearing a string of beads associated with the Santeria religion and a multicolored bandana linked to Native American beliefs. According to prison policy, inmates may only wear religious items associated with their declared religion.

When Officer Grizzanti confronted Waters about the bandana, Waters became argumentative. To de-escalate the situation, Grizzanti placed Waters in a holding cell and contacted the prison’s Supervisory Chaplain for clarification on the religious items. After confirming that Waters had permission for the Santeria beads, Grizzanti returned to explain the situation. However, Waters became agitated, leading to a physical altercation involving multiple officers.

During the struggle, Waters allegedly struck Officer Grizzanti multiple times and bit two other officers, resulting in injuries. The trial featured conflicting testimonies regarding whether Waters used a baton during the assault. Ultimately, the jury found Waters guilty on all counts, leading to his appeal against the conviction and sentence.

The Ruling

The Third Circuit, including Judges Restrepo, McKee, and Ambro, upheld the District Court's decision, affirming Waters' conviction and sentence. The court addressed Waters' claims regarding his right to self-representation, stating, "The District Court did not violate Waters’s right to proceed pro se." The court noted that Waters had not clearly and unequivocally requested to represent himself, as he had been represented by counsel throughout the trial.

Regarding the sentencing enhancements, the court ruled that the District Court did not err in applying enhancements for using a dangerous weapon and for obstruction of justice. The court stated, "The District Court did not clearly err by enhancing Waters’s sentence under U.S.S.G. § 2A2.2(b)(2)(B) for using a dangerous weapon." This finding was based on the testimony of Lieutenant Young, who witnessed Waters using the baton during the altercation.

Impact

The ruling by the Third Circuit reinforces the legal standards surrounding inmate conduct and the application of sentencing enhancements in cases involving assaults against law enforcement officers. It highlights the importance of maintaining order within correctional facilities and the legal consequences that inmates face when engaging in violent behavior. This case may serve as a reference for future cases involving similar circumstances, particularly regarding the use of weapons and the implications of self-defense claims within the prison system.

Furthermore, the court's decision emphasizes the significance of procedural rights for defendants, particularly the right to self-representation. The ruling clarifies the conditions under which a court must conduct a Faretta inquiry to ensure that a defendant understands the risks of representing themselves.

What's Next

Waters' conviction and sentence can potentially be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, although it remains unclear if he will pursue further legal action. There are no related cases pending that were mentioned in the court filing. The Third Circuit's decision stands as the final ruling on this matter unless further challenged.