The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals has affirmed the dismissal of a claim by James Hsieh against PitchBook Data, Inc., ruling that his lawsuit was filed too late. This decision, made on November 18, 2026, affects individuals who believe their privacy rights have been violated under Illinois law. The court's ruling clarifies the statute of limitations for claims under the Illinois Right of Publicity Act (IRPA), which is now confirmed to be one year.

Hsieh, a professional in the private equity sector, filed his lawsuit more than three years after PitchBook added his personal information to its database without his consent. The court's decision emphasizes the importance of timely legal action in privacy rights cases and reinforces the one-year statute of limitations previously established in a related case.

Background

James Hsieh is the plaintiff in this case, and he brought his claim against PitchBook Data, Inc., a company that operates a website providing access to a database of professionals in private equity, venture capital, and mergers and acquisitions. Hsieh's employer shared his name, email, and job title with PitchBook on February 8, 2021. Just a week later, PitchBook included Hsieh's information in its database without obtaining his consent.

Over three years later, in October 2024, Hsieh filed a lawsuit in Illinois state court, claiming that PitchBook violated the Illinois Right of Publicity Act by using his identity for commercial purposes without his permission. The case was later moved to federal court after PitchBook invoked the Class Action Fairness Act. The core of the dispute centered on whether Hsieh's claim fell within the one-year statute of limitations for privacy claims, as argued by PitchBook.

The Ruling

The Seventh Circuit, led by Judge Scudder, ruled that Hsieh's claim was indeed untimely. The court affirmed the district court's dismissal based on the one-year statute of limitations established in previous cases, specifically citing the earlier decision in Giovannelli v. Walmart Inc. The court stated, "Absent signals from the state courts or other developments that call into question an earlier Erie Railroad prediction, we leave our precedent undisturbed." This reinforces that Hsieh's claim was filed too late, as he brought it more than three years after PitchBook published his information.

The court also noted that while Hsieh argued that the IRPA should be treated as a property right with a five-year statute of limitations, the court found no evidence that Illinois courts would rule differently than they did in the past. The court emphasized that the one-year statute of limitations applies to claims under the IRPA, and Hsieh's claim did not meet this requirement.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for individuals seeking to file claims under the Illinois Right of Publicity Act. It confirms that claims must be filed within one year of the alleged violation, which may deter some potential plaintiffs from pursuing their cases if they do not act quickly. This decision also strengthens the precedent set in previous cases, making it clear that the one-year statute of limitations will continue to apply to IRPA claims.

The court's affirmation of the district court's ruling may also influence how future cases are approached, as it underscores the importance of adhering to established legal timelines. Individuals who believe their privacy rights have been violated must now be more vigilant about the timing of their legal actions to avoid dismissal on similar grounds.

What's Next

Hsieh's case can be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, but it is unclear if he will pursue that option. There are no related cases pending that could impact this ruling. The court's decision stands as a significant interpretation of Illinois privacy law and will likely guide future litigation in this area.