The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has denied the asylum petition of Maria Encarnacion Ramirez-Cumpar and her minor child, both from Guatemala. The court ruled on November 19, 2026, in case number 25-3357, stating that the family did not challenge key findings from the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) regarding their case. This decision affects their ability to remain in the United States and highlights the challenges many immigrants face in securing asylum.

Maria Encarnacion Ramirez-Cumpar, along with her child, sought asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT) after their applications were denied by an immigration judge (IJ). The BIA upheld this decision, leading the family to appeal to the Ninth Circuit. The ruling is significant as it underscores the stringent requirements for asylum seekers and the legal complexities involved in immigration cases.

Background

Maria Encarnacion Ramirez-Cumpar and her child are natives of Guatemala. They applied for asylum in the United States, claiming a fear of persecution if they returned to their home country. Their case was initially heard by an immigration judge, who denied their requests for asylum and other protections. The judge found that the family failed to establish a credible fear of persecution based on a protected ground.

After the IJ's ruling, Ramirez-Cumpar appealed to the BIA, which dismissed the appeal. The BIA's decision indicated that the petitioners had waived their right to challenge the IJ's key findings. This led them to seek a review from the Ninth Circuit, where they hoped to overturn the BIA's dismissal and secure their right to stay in the U.S.

The Ruling

The Ninth Circuit reviewed the case and ultimately denied the petition for review. The court stated, "Petitioners do not challenge the BIA’s conclusion that they waived review of the IJ’s dispositive determination that they failed to show any nexus to a protected ground for asylum and withholding of removal." This highlights that the family did not contest the BIA's findings regarding their claims, which were crucial to the court's decision.

The ruling also noted that the petitioners did not challenge the BIA's denial of CAT protection. As a result, the court did not address these issues in its opinion. The judges on the panel included Christen, Bumatay, and Sanchez, who unanimously agreed on the decision.

Impact

The denial of this appeal has significant implications for Ramirez-Cumpar and her child. Without the ability to secure asylum, they face the possibility of removal from the United States. This case illustrates the difficulties many immigrants encounter when navigating the U.S. immigration system, especially when they lack legal representation. The ruling emphasizes the importance of challenging all aspects of a decision when appealing to higher courts.

Furthermore, this case may serve as a cautionary tale for other asylum seekers. It underscores the necessity of presenting a strong case that addresses all required legal standards, particularly the need to demonstrate a connection to a protected ground for asylum. The ruling does not set a new precedent but reaffirms existing legal principles regarding asylum claims.

What's Next

Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether the family plans to appeal this decision further. However, they may seek other forms of relief or reconsideration based on new evidence or legal arguments. The outcome of this case could influence similar cases involving asylum seekers from Guatemala and other countries facing similar challenges.