In a significant ruling, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has remanded the asylum case of Okunlola Oluwaseun Kolawole, a Nigerian citizen, back to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) for further review. The court's decision, filed on November 19, 2026, addresses key issues surrounding Kolawole's claims for asylum, withholding of removal, and protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT). This ruling affects Kolawole and potentially many others in similar situations, as it clarifies the standards for credibility and eligibility for voluntary departure in immigration proceedings.
Kolawole's case began when he sought asylum in the United States after fleeing Nigeria, where he claimed to have suffered persecution from the terrorist group Boko Haram. The Immigration Judge (IJ) initially denied Kolawole's asylum application, leading to an appeal to the BIA. The BIA upheld the IJ's decision, citing issues with Kolawole's credibility and inconsistencies in his testimony. Kolawole then petitioned the Ninth Circuit for review, which has now granted part of his request.
The dispute centers on Kolawole's claims of persecution based on his religious beliefs and the violent attacks he faced in Nigeria. The BIA's decision to dismiss his appeal raised questions about the credibility of his testimony and the evidence he provided. Kolawole argued that the IJ and BIA improperly assessed his credibility and failed to consider significant legal precedents that could impact his case.
The Ninth Circuit's ruling addressed several key points. First, the court determined that Kolawole is eligible for voluntary departure due to a recent clarification in the law regarding the service of a defective Notice to Appear (NTA). The court stated, "Under Posos-Sanchez, Kolawole now meets the one-year presence requirement for voluntary departure." This means that Kolawole can now apply for voluntary departure, which allows him to leave the U.S. voluntarily rather than being forcibly removed.
Secondly, the court found that the BIA erred in applying a frivolousness bar to Kolawole's asylum application based on minor inconsistencies regarding the date of the Boko Haram attack on his village. The court noted, "The agency erred in applying the frivolousness bar based on a minor, explained inconsistency regarding the exact date of the attack." The Ninth Circuit emphasized that such discrepancies should not undermine Kolawole's entire claim for asylum.
However, the court upheld some of the BIA's findings, particularly regarding Kolawole's credibility. The court found that while certain inconsistencies in Kolawole's testimony were not sufficient to discredit him entirely, others were supported by substantial evidence. For example, the court noted that Kolawole's statements about the timing and cause of his father's death were inconsistent and required further clarification from the BIA.
The ruling was delivered by a panel of judges, including Judges Paez, Christen, and Miller, with Judge Miller issuing a partial concurrence and dissent. The court's decision to remand the case means that the BIA must reevaluate Kolawole's credibility and consider the implications of the recent legal standards regarding voluntary departure and frivolousness.
This ruling is significant not only for Kolawole but also for others seeking asylum in the U.S. It reinforces the importance of fair and thorough assessments of credibility in immigration cases. The court's decision highlights that minor inconsistencies should not automatically discredit an applicant's claims, especially when those inconsistencies do not impact the core of the asylum claim.
Moving forward, Kolawole's case will be sent back to the BIA for a new credibility determination and to allow him to apply for voluntary departure. The Ninth Circuit's ruling may set a precedent for similar cases, emphasizing the need for immigration judges and the BIA to provide clear reasoning for their credibility assessments.
As for the next steps, Kolawole's case can be appealed again if the BIA's new decision is unfavorable. There are no related cases pending that directly impact this ruling, but the implications of this decision could resonate in future immigration cases involving asylum claims.
Read Next
Court affirms dismissal of bankruptcy appeal by Moda
Ninth Circuit denies Gonzalez-Alfaro's appeal on removal
Ninth Circuit denies asylum for Honduran mother, daughter
Fifth Circuit affirms sentence in illegal reentry case
Court denies asylum petition from Colombian mother, child
Court Rules on Immigration Petition Denial in Christian Case










