The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled in favor of Affiliated FM Insurance Company, affirming a lower court's decision that Tower Crossing Condominium Association's claim for storm damage was filed too late. The ruling, issued on November 19, 2026, affects Tower Crossing, which manages a condominium complex in Glenview, Illinois, and could have implications for how insurance claims are processed in the future.

This case, Tower Crossing Condominium Association v. Affiliated FM Insurance Company (Docket No. 25-3167), centers around a dispute over a $4.3 million insurance claim for storm damage. The court's decision highlights the importance of adhering to specific requirements outlined in insurance policies, particularly regarding the submission of a sworn proof of loss.

Tower Crossing Condominium Association, the plaintiff in this case, manages a condominium complex and had an all-risk insurance policy with Affiliated FM Insurance Company, which covered the complex from May 1, 2018, to May 1, 2020. The dispute arose after a storm damaged the roof of the complex on July 2, 2019. Following the damage, Tower Crossing submitted a notice of the damage to Affiliated FM on August 21, 2019, initiating a two-year period of negotiations between the parties.

As the two-year limitations period was about to expire, Affiliated FM agreed to extend the deadline for Tower Crossing to file a lawsuit until October 2, 2021. However, negotiations stalled, and Tower Crossing submitted a proof of loss with a valuation of $4,341,149.36 just one day before the extended deadline. The issue arose because the proof of loss submitted was not “sworn” as required by the policy, leading to the district court granting Affiliated FM's motion for summary judgment.

The court found that Tower Crossing's proof of loss did not meet the policy's requirement for a “signed and sworn” document. The court noted that the proof of loss submitted did not include an oath, which is necessary for it to be considered valid under the terms of the insurance policy. Chief Judge Brennan, along with Judges Easterbrook and Kirsch, ruled that the limitations period had expired before Tower Crossing filed its lawsuit, making the claim time-barred.

The court ruled, "Tower Crossing did not submit a 'sworn' proof of loss as required by the policy, and substantial compliance does not trigger tolling of the applicable limitations period."

The court's ruling emphasized that the term “sworn” requires an oath, and simply submitting a document with a signature does not fulfill this requirement. The judges referenced the Illinois insurance code, which states that limitations periods are tolled only when a proof of loss is filed in the required form.

In addition to the specific requirements of the insurance policy, the court addressed Tower Crossing's argument that it had substantially complied with the proof of loss requirement. However, the court found that substantial compliance is not sufficient to trigger the tolling of the limitations period when the policy explicitly requires a sworn proof of loss. The court stated that the policy's language must be followed precisely, and the absence of the required oath meant that the limitations period was not tolled.

This ruling has significant implications for Tower Crossing and may set a precedent for future insurance claims. The court's decision reinforces the necessity for policyholders to adhere strictly to the terms of their insurance agreements, particularly regarding the submission of proofs of loss. Insurers may now have a clearer basis to deny claims that do not comply with specific policy requirements.

The ruling also serves as a reminder for condominium associations and other entities to ensure that all necessary documentation is properly completed and submitted in accordance with their insurance policies. Failure to do so could result in the loss of the right to seek compensation for damages, as seen in this case.

Looking ahead, Tower Crossing has the option to appeal the decision to the U.S. Supreme Court, although it is unclear whether they will pursue this route. There are currently no related cases pending that could affect this ruling.