The U.S. Court of International Trade has ordered the U.S. Department of Commerce to revisit its final decision regarding antidumping duties on aluminum foil imported from Oman. This ruling affects Oman Aluminium Rolling Company SPC and could have broader implications for U.S. trade practices and compliance standards in the aluminum industry.

On November 19, 2026, Judge Jennifer Choe-Groves issued the ruling in case number 25-00215, which centers on the U.S. Department of Commerce's determination in its administrative review of certain aluminum foil from Oman. The case highlights the complexities of international trade regulations and the importance of accurate reporting by manufacturers.

Background

The dispute began when the U.S. Department of Commerce initiated an administrative review of antidumping duties on aluminum foil from Oman in December 2023. This review aimed to assess whether Oman Aluminium Rolling Company had been selling its products at unfairly low prices in the U.S. market.

During the review, Commerce issued multiple questionnaires to Oman Aluminium, seeking detailed information about its pricing and freight expenses. However, the Aluminum Association Trade Enforcement Working Group and its members, including Gränges Americas and JW Aluminum, raised concerns about the accuracy of Oman Aluminium’s responses, particularly regarding the allocation of freight expenses.

In September 2025, Commerce published its final results, determining that Oman Aluminium had misreported its freight expenses and revenues. This led to the application of adverse facts available, which increased the duties imposed on the company. Oman Aluminium and Daikin Comfort Technologies North America, Inc., which intervened in support of Oman Aluminium, challenged this determination in court.

The Ruling

The court ruled in favor of Oman Aluminium, stating that Commerce's decision to apply adverse facts available was not supported by substantial evidence. Judge Choe-Groves noted, "Commerce’s determinations that Plaintiff withheld information regarding its freight expense allocation methodology and its freight revenue reporting were neither supported by substantial evidence nor in accordance with law."

The court found that Commerce had failed to provide adequate notice to Oman Aluminium regarding deficiencies in its reporting and did not allow the company a fair opportunity to address these issues. The judge emphasized that Commerce must inform respondents of any deficiencies and allow them to remedy these issues as part of the review process.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for the aluminum industry and international trade practices. It underscores the necessity for the U.S. Department of Commerce to adhere to procedural fairness when conducting administrative reviews. The decision may also encourage other companies facing similar challenges to contest adverse findings if they believe their reporting was accurate and compliant.

The court's ruling may set a precedent for future cases involving antidumping duties, particularly regarding the standards of evidence required for Commerce to apply adverse facts available. This could lead to more rigorous scrutiny of how the Department of Commerce conducts its reviews and the importance of providing clear guidance to companies regarding their reporting obligations.

What's Next

The case has been remanded to the U.S. Department of Commerce for further review and explanation consistent with the court's opinion. It remains to be seen how Commerce will respond to the court's ruling and whether Oman Aluminium will face any changes in its duty rates as a result of the remand. There are no indications that the ruling will be appealed at this time.