A U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., has denied a motion from Richard Roe, a non-party, seeking to intervene in a criminal forfeiture case involving cryptocurrency stolen from the Bitfinex exchange. This ruling affects Roe and potentially other claimants who may have been impacted by the defendants' actions. The case highlights the complexities of cryptocurrency theft and the legal proceedings surrounding it.
The case, United States v. Morgan, was filed under docket number 23-cr-239 (CKK) and involves defendants Ilya Lichtenstein and Heather Morgan. Both pleaded guilty to charges related to a conspiracy to launder money, stemming from a significant hack of Bitfinex in 2016 that resulted in the theft of millions in cryptocurrency. The court's decision is significant as it clarifies the process for third parties seeking to claim interests in forfeited assets.
Background
The defendants, Lichtenstein and Morgan, were involved in a high-profile case concerning a hack of the Bitfinex cryptocurrency exchange, where approximately $4.5 billion was stolen. Following their guilty pleas, the court initiated a forfeiture proceeding to determine the fate of the stolen assets. Bitfinex, as the victim of the hack, is seeking restitution, while various third parties, including Roe, have claimed interests in the forfeited property.
The case has seen numerous motions filed by potential claimants seeking to intervene and assert their rights to the forfeited assets. The court has been tasked with navigating the complexities of these claims, particularly given the nature of cryptocurrency and the difficulties in tracing ownership. The legal proceedings have involved extensive documentation and multiple hearings to address the claims of various petitioners.
The Ruling
Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly ruled on November 19, 2026, denying Roe's motion to file an out-of-time motion to intervene. The court stated, "Roe has not demonstrated excusable neglect under the applicable legal standards." The ruling emphasized that the government had fulfilled its notification obligations regarding the forfeiture proceedings, which included public notices and attempts to reach potential claimants.
The court's opinion noted that Roe's claim was submitted after the statutory deadline for filing petitions had expired. The judge highlighted that the government had published notices and provided sufficient information to the public about the forfeiture process, which Roe failed to respond to in a timely manner. The ruling also addressed Roe's argument regarding not receiving direct notice, stating that direct notification was not required under the law.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for Roe and other potential claimants who may have hoped to assert their interests in the forfeited cryptocurrency. The court's decision reinforces the importance of adhering to statutory deadlines in legal proceedings, particularly in complex cases involving multiple parties and competing claims. It also underscores the challenges faced by individuals seeking to navigate the legal landscape of cryptocurrency theft and forfeiture.
The outcome of this case may set a precedent for future cases involving cryptocurrency and forfeiture, clarifying the obligations of the government regarding notifications and the rights of third parties to intervene in such proceedings. As cryptocurrency continues to be a growing area of interest in legal contexts, this ruling may influence how similar cases are handled in the future.
What's Next
Roe's motion cannot be appealed as the court has made a definitive ruling on the matter. However, the case continues with ongoing proceedings related to the claims of Bitfinex and other petitioners seeking restitution for their alleged losses. The court may address additional motions related to the forfeiture assets in the future, as the complexities of this case unfold.
Read Next
Court stays enforcement of ICSID award in Telefonica case
Court Denies Pseudonym for Plaintiff in Doe v. Trump Case
Court Allows Pseudonymous Filing in Iran Torture Case
Court dismisses Rhashema Shackleford's appeal motion
Arkansas Supreme Court upholds dismissal of McClinton's appeal
Texas Court of Appeals upholds manslaughter conviction










