In a recent ruling, the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York upheld the classification of James Hewitt as a risk level three sex offender. This decision, made on November 19, 2026, affects Hewitt, who was previously convicted of multiple offenses involving the surreptitious filming of minors. The ruling emphasizes the seriousness of his actions and the potential risk he poses to the community.

The case arose from a 2020 incident where Hewitt and his wife filmed children under 17 years old in varying states of nudity in a public restroom at an amusement park. They used a pen equipped with a hidden camera to carry out these acts. Following his guilty plea, Hewitt received a prison sentence of 2 to 6 years. As he approached his release, the Board of Examiners of Sex Offenders prepared a risk assessment instrument that initially classified him as a risk level two offender.

However, the prosecution sought to increase this classification to a risk level three, citing additional criminal activity in Albany County. This included similar offenses committed before the Warren County incidents, which were not considered in the initial risk assessment. The case was brought before the County Court of Warren County, where the judge ruled in favor of the prosecution's request for an upward departure in risk classification.

The court found that the evidence presented by the prosecution clearly supported the need for a higher classification. In the ruling, the court stated, "An upward departure from a presumptive risk level classification is justified when an aggravating factor exists that is not otherwise adequately taken into account by the risk assessment guidelines." This ruling was based on the concurrent offenses in Albany County, which involved unlawful surveillance of minors in public restrooms.

Hewitt's defense did not contest the initial classification of 100 points, which placed him at risk level two. Instead, he argued that the County Court erred in granting the prosecution's request for an upward departure. The court, however, found that the aggravating factors presented by the prosecution were compelling enough to warrant the increase in classification. They noted that the concurrent offenses in Albany County indicated a higher likelihood of reoffense and a greater danger to public safety.

The court emphasized that the totality of circumstances surrounding Hewitt's actions, particularly the surreptitious recording of multiple unsuspecting victims, including young children, justified the upward departure. The ruling highlighted that such behavior across different jurisdictions demonstrated a significant risk of recidivism.

As a result of this ruling, Hewitt remains classified as a risk level three sex offender, which carries more stringent monitoring and registration requirements. This classification serves to protect the public, particularly vulnerable populations such as children, from potential harm.

The decision has broader implications for similar cases involving sex offenders. It reinforces the importance of considering an offender's complete criminal history, including concurrent offenses, when determining risk levels under the Sex Offender Registration Act. This ruling may influence future cases where offenders have multiple convictions that could indicate a higher risk to public safety.

Looking ahead, it is unclear whether Hewitt will appeal this decision. The court's ruling does allow for the possibility of an appeal, but further details were not available in the court filing regarding any potential next steps. The case serves as a critical reminder of the legal system's commitment to community safety and the careful assessment of offenders' risks.