The Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals has dismissed the appeal of Tre' Anthony Roberts, who was sentenced to 140 months in prison for coercion and enticement of a minor. The court ruled that Roberts' appeal was barred by a sentence appeal waiver included in his plea agreement. This decision underscores the importance of plea agreements in criminal cases and the limitations they can impose on defendants seeking to challenge their sentences.
Roberts, who was charged with multiple offenses involving sexual exploitation of a minor, entered a plea agreement in which he pled guilty to one count of coercion and enticement. The plea agreement included a waiver that restricted his ability to appeal the sentence. The court's ruling highlights the significance of understanding the terms of such agreements, especially when they include waivers that limit the right to appeal.
In July 2025, a grand jury indicted Roberts on three counts related to sexual offenses against a minor. The charges included attempted production of material involving sexual exploitation of a minor and two counts of coercion and enticement. After entering a plea agreement, Roberts admitted to engaging in inappropriate communications with his sixteen-year-old cousin, which included inducing her to engage in sexual activity and produce child pornography.
The plea agreement allowed Roberts to plead guilty to the second count while the other two counts were dismissed. As part of the agreement, Roberts waived his right to appeal his sentence except under specific circumstances, such as if the sentence exceeded the maximum allowed by law or if the government appealed the sentence. The district court confirmed that Roberts understood the plea agreement and the implications of the waiver during the change-of-plea hearing.
During sentencing, the district court imposed a 140-month prison term, which fell within the calculated guidelines range of 135 to 168 months. The government had recommended a sentence of 120 months, but the court decided on a longer sentence, considering factors such as Roberts' previous role as a correctional officer and the nature of his offense against a family member.
Roberts filed an appeal arguing that his sentence was unreasonable and that the district court erred by not allowing him to personally address the court before sentencing. However, the government moved to dismiss the appeal, asserting that Roberts had knowingly and voluntarily waived his right to appeal as part of the plea agreement.
The court agreed with the government, stating that Roberts had indeed entered into the waiver knowingly and voluntarily. The ruling emphasized that the waiver was valid and that Roberts' arguments fell within the terms of the waiver. The court noted that the plea agreement provided a benefit to Roberts by allowing him to avoid potentially harsher penalties associated with the other counts that were dismissed.
The Eleventh Circuit concluded that Roberts' claims did not meet the criteria for the “miscarriage of justice” exception, which would allow an appeal despite a waiver. The court found that the errors Roberts alleged were not egregious enough to warrant such an exception. The ruling pointed out that the alleged failure to allow Roberts to personally allocute did not rise to the level of a fundamental defect that would undermine the integrity of the judicial process.
This dismissal means that Roberts will serve his sentence without the possibility of appeal based on the arguments he presented. The court's decision reinforces the enforceability of plea agreements and the waivers they often contain, which can limit a defendant's ability to challenge their sentence after accepting a plea deal.
The implications of this ruling extend beyond Roberts' case, as it serves as a reminder to defendants about the importance of understanding the terms of plea agreements. Defendants must be aware of the potential consequences of waiving their right to appeal, as it can significantly impact their ability to contest their sentences later.
Looking ahead, it is unclear if Roberts will seek further legal avenues, such as filing a petition for post-conviction relief. However, the current ruling effectively concludes his appeal process in the Eleventh Circuit. The court’s decision may also influence future cases involving plea agreements and the enforceability of appeal waivers, highlighting the need for defendants to be fully informed before entering such agreements.
Read Next
Court affirms sentence for embezzler Zachary Rugen
Court affirms dismissal of Griffin's arbitration appeal
Court affirms sentence for Alfredo Graham's violations
Fifth Circuit affirms sentence in bank robbery case
Fifth Circuit denies habeas relief for convicted murderer Mata
Fifth Circuit upholds conviction of Miguel Keelen, modifies release terms










