A New York appellate court has modified the sentence of Antonio R. Provost, who was convicted of robbery and burglary. The Appellate Division of the Supreme Court ruled on November 19, 2026, that Provost's sentences for both crimes should run concurrently instead of consecutively. This decision comes after Provost appealed his original sentencing, which he argued was unduly harsh.

The case stems from a home invasion robbery that occurred in November 2020 in Chesterfield, Essex County. Provost and an accomplice allegedly threatened residents with a firearm and physically assaulted one of them during the incident. Following his arrest, Provost faced a 20-count indictment related to the crimes.

In September 2021, Provost entered a plea agreement, admitting guilt to one count each of robbery in the second degree and burglary in the second degree. As part of the agreement, he waived his right to appeal, although the court did not guarantee a specific sentence. The plea deal outlined a potential sentencing range of 3½ to 15 years in prison, with the understanding that the sentences would run concurrently.

However, during the plea allocution, the County Court indicated it might impose consecutive sentences. Ultimately, Provost received a 12-year sentence for burglary and a 15-year sentence for robbery, both followed by five years of post-release supervision. Provost objected to this consecutive sentencing.

On appeal, Provost argued that the County Court had initially reversed its decision to impose consecutive sentences two months after his sentencing, suggesting that the court believed the sentences were too harsh. The appellate court noted that while such a reversal would raise significant concerns, the record did not confirm that the court had actually resentenced Provost. Instead, the court had invited him to make a proper motion, which he did not pursue.

The appellate judges considered Provost's challenge to his sentence, stating that it survived the appeal waiver because of the ambiguous language used during the plea colloquy. They noted that the County Court did not clearly state that the appeal waiver would prevent Provost from contesting any sentence exceeding the agreed-upon range.

In their ruling, the court stated, "on this record, and after accounting for the circumstances set forth in the [presentence report], that the sentence was unduly harsh and severe to the extent that consecutive terms of imprisonment were imposed." The court modified the original judgment, ordering that Provost's sentences run concurrently.

The judges who participated in the decision included Presiding Justice Garry, and Justices Aarons, McShan, and Corcoran.

This ruling is significant as it highlights the discretion courts have in sentencing and the importance of clear communication during plea agreements. The decision also serves as a reminder that defendants have rights that must be respected, even when they waive their right to appeal.

The modification of Provost's sentence means he will serve a shorter overall time in prison than initially imposed. This outcome may impact how similar cases are handled in the future, particularly regarding plea agreements and sentencing practices.

As for what happens next, it is unclear if Provost will pursue any further legal action. The court filing did not indicate any related cases pending or whether he plans to appeal the modified sentence.