The Florida District Court of Appeal has upheld the life sentence of Jason J. Butler, who was convicted of attempted second-degree murder, attempted robbery with a firearm, aggravated assault, and possession of a firearm by a convicted felon. The court ruled on November 18, 2026, in case number 4D2025-1319, affirming the lower court's decision and rejecting Butler's arguments for appeal.

This ruling affects Butler, who will continue to serve his life sentence, and it may have broader implications for others facing similar charges in Florida. The court's decision reinforces the legal standards surrounding firearm possession by felons and the severity of sentences for violent crimes.

Background

Jason J. Butler was convicted in the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit Court in Broward County. The charges against him included attempted second-degree murder and attempted robbery with a firearm, which are serious offenses in Florida. Additionally, Butler faced charges of aggravated assault and possession of a firearm by a convicted felon, as outlined in section 790.23 of the Florida Statutes.

The case reached the District Court of Appeal after Butler appealed his convictions and life sentence. He raised several issues during his appeal, including constitutional challenges to the laws under which he was convicted. The appeal sought to overturn the convictions and potentially reduce his sentence.

The Ruling

The court ruled unanimously to affirm Butler's convictions and life sentence. In addressing Butler's arguments, the court noted that none of the issues he raised warranted relief. Specifically, Butler argued that section 790.23, which prohibits firearm possession by convicted felons, violated both the Florida Constitution and the United States Constitution. However, the court relied on precedents such as Nelson v. State and Fleming v. State to uphold the constitutionality of the statute.

The court stated, "We rely upon Nelson v. State, 195 So. 2d 853 (Fla. 1967), and Fleming v. State, 414 So. 3d 175 (Fla. 4th DCA 2025), to affirm these issues." This indicates that the court found sufficient legal grounding in previous cases to reject Butler's constitutional claims.

Furthermore, Butler contended that he was denied his right to a twelve-member jury, which he argued constituted a fundamental error by the circuit court. The court, however, affirmed this issue as well, referencing Guzman v. State and noting that the matter had been previously addressed in the courts.

Impact

The court's decision has significant implications for Butler and others in similar situations. By upholding the life sentence, the ruling reinforces the strict penalties associated with violent crimes, particularly those involving firearms. It also confirms the legality of Florida's statute regarding firearm possession by felons, which has been a contentious issue in legal circles.

This ruling may deter individuals from engaging in similar criminal behavior, knowing that the courts are likely to impose severe penalties for such actions. Additionally, the affirmation of the jury composition issue may influence future cases where defendants challenge the size and makeup of juries.

What's Next

Butler's legal team may file a motion for rehearing, as the court's decision is not final until such a motion is resolved. If the motion is denied, Butler could potentially seek further review from the Florida Supreme Court, depending on the legal strategies employed by his attorneys. Details regarding any related cases or further appeals were not available in the court filing.