A Florida court has ruled on the appeal of Scott Joseph Trader, who was convicted of lewd or lascivious molestation and sexual battery against a child under twelve. The District Court of Appeal of Florida issued its opinion on November 18, 2026, in case number 4D2025-1213. The court's ruling has significant implications for Trader, as it addresses both his conviction and the controversial sentencing involving medical treatment.
Trader's case stems from charges filed in 2016, which included multiple sexually-based offenses against two different victims. After a trial in 2023, he was convicted on all counts. However, the court previously reversed and remanded the convictions due to misjoinder, meaning the charges against the two victims should not have been combined in one trial. Following this, Trader represented himself in a retrial, where he was again found guilty.
Upon conviction, the trial court sentenced Trader to two life sentences and mandated treatment with medroxyprogesterone acetate (MPA), a hormone treatment often used to reduce sexual urges. Trader objected to this treatment, leading to a legal dispute over its appropriateness and the process by which it was ordered.
Background
Scott Joseph Trader was initially charged in 2016 with serious sexual offenses involving minors. The charges included lewd or lascivious molestation and sexual battery against a child under twelve. The State of Florida sought to prosecute him for these crimes, which led to his conviction after a retrial in 2023.
The case became complicated when Trader appealed his convictions based on several legal arguments. He contended that the trial court made errors by denying motions to disqualify, for a statement of particulars, and to suppress evidence. Additionally, he argued that the court erred in sentencing him to MPA treatment and that he was entitled to a twelve-person jury, rather than the six-person jury that was impaneled.
In a previous ruling, the court had already addressed issues of misjoinder, leading to a remand for a new trial. This history of legal challenges set the stage for Trader's appeal regarding his sentencing and the treatment order.
The Ruling
The court ruled on several aspects of Trader's appeal. It affirmed the trial court's decisions regarding the denial of motions to disqualify and to suppress evidence. However, the court reversed the order requiring Trader to undergo MPA treatment. The opinion stated, "The trial court lacked jurisdiction to enter the order striking the MPA treatment because the defendant had already filed his notice of appeal." This indicates that the trial court acted beyond its authority after Trader's appeal was filed.
Judge May authored the opinion, with Judges Shepherd and Shaw concurring. The court noted that the trial court's order striking the MPA treatment was entered after Trader's notice of appeal, which generally means the court loses jurisdiction over the case. As a result, the issue of MPA treatment was not moot, and the court reversed the requirement for Trader to receive this treatment.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for Scott Trader, as it reverses a part of his sentencing that could have had long-term effects on his health and treatment. The court's decision also clarifies the legal process surrounding the imposition of MPA treatment, emphasizing the need for proper jurisdiction and procedure before such orders can be made.
Furthermore, the ruling may set a precedent for similar cases involving mandatory treatment for sexual offenders in Florida. It highlights the importance of following legal protocols when sentencing individuals to medical treatments, especially in cases involving serious crimes against children. The court's emphasis on jurisdiction may also influence how trial courts handle post-appeal orders in the future.
What's Next
Following this ruling, it is unclear whether Trader will pursue further appeals regarding his conviction itself, as the court affirmed the trial court's decision to impanel a six-person jury. The case may also prompt discussions about the constitutionality of MPA treatment in other contexts. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases or further legal actions Trader might take.
Read Next
Florida Court Affirms Eviction Judgment Against Tenant
Florida court affirms decision in Kelsey v. State of Florida
Florida Court Sanctions Disbarred Lawyer for Frivolous Filings
California Court Transfers Juvenile F.V. to Adult Criminal Court
Pennsylvania court affirms murder conviction of Aaron Johnson
Pennsylvania court affirms sentence in domestic violence case










