A Delaware court recently issued a ruling in the case of PPG Industries, Inc. v. Westlake Corporation, C.A. No. 2024-0648-NAC, that addresses a complex dispute stemming from a significant maritime incident. The decision impacts PPG Industries, its spun-off entities, and their insurance obligations regarding a lawsuit in Brazil, which has resulted in substantial financial implications.

The court ruled on November 18, 2026, following a series of legal battles over the liability for damages arising from a fire on the cargo ship DG Harmony in 1998. This ruling is crucial as it clarifies the responsibilities of PPG Industries and its spun-off entities regarding the ongoing Di Gregorio litigation in Brazil.

Background

The parties involved in this case include PPG Industries, Inc., an industrial conglomerate based in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and Westlake Corporation, along with its subsidiaries, which were spun off from PPG. The dispute originates from a fire on the DG Harmony, a cargo ship that caught fire off the coast of Brazil, leading to multiple lawsuits against PPG. In 2009, a New York court found PPG liable for the incident, resulting in a settlement of $81.5 million.

In 2013, PPG spun off its commodity chemicals business, transferring certain liabilities, including the ongoing Di Gregorio litigation, to Westlake’s subsidiaries. However, PPG retained its insurance policies that covered these liabilities. As the Di Gregorio litigation progressed, PPG and Westlake found themselves in conflict over insurance rights and responsibilities for the mounting legal costs.

The Ruling

The court's decision denied PPG's requests for specific performance, which sought to have Westlake take over the defense in the Di Gregorio litigation and post a bond to secure a judgment. The court stated, "Even assuming PPG has proven a breach of contract, it has not shown, by clear and convincing evidence, that specific performance is appropriate." The ruling emphasized that PPG's delay in seeking substitution for 11 years after the spinoff raised concerns about the appropriateness of such an order.

Furthermore, the court granted Westlake’s request for an assignment of insurance proceeds, but only for the costs of defending PPG in the Di Gregorio litigation that had already been incurred. The ruling highlighted that the spun-off entities are ultimately responsible for any enforceable judgment and related losses, and they continue to defend the Di Gregorio litigation while holding PPG harmless against any enforcement attempts.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for both PPG and Westlake. It clarifies the contractual obligations between the parties regarding the Di Gregorio litigation and the associated insurance rights. By denying PPG's request for specific performance, the court has reinforced the importance of timely actions in legal disputes, especially regarding liability and insurance claims.

The decision also underscores the complexities involved in corporate spinoffs, particularly concerning the allocation of liabilities and insurance coverage. As the spun-off entities continue to manage the Di Gregorio litigation, this ruling may serve as a precedent for similar disputes in the future, emphasizing the need for clear contractual agreements in corporate transactions.

What's Next

Following this ruling, it remains to be seen whether PPG will appeal the decision. The court's opinion leaves open the possibility for further legal maneuvers as both parties navigate the ongoing litigation in Brazil. Additionally, the broader implications of this case may influence how companies structure their spinoffs and manage their liabilities in the future.