The Superior Court of Pennsylvania has upheld the DUI conviction of Alyssa A. Murray, affirming that sufficient evidence supported the finding that she was under the influence of a controlled substance while driving. The ruling, issued on November 17, 2026, affects Murray, who was sentenced to probation and fines following her conviction in the Lebanon County Court of Common Pleas.

The case stemmed from an incident that occurred on August 8, 2024, when Murray was pulled over by South Lebanon Township Police Officer Christopher Moser for driving without her headlights on. The court's decision emphasizes the importance of the evidence presented during the trial, particularly the observations made by Officer Moser and the results of field sobriety tests.

Background

Alyssa A. Murray was the appellant in this case, appealing her conviction for DUI of a controlled substance and related offenses. The incident began when Officer Moser observed her vehicle driving at night without headlights. After initially failing to stop for several miles, Murray eventually pulled over but then drove away again when the officer approached her. This led to her eventual arrest.

During the traffic stop, Officer Moser noted several signs of impairment, including Murray's droopy eyelids and confused demeanor. He conducted field sobriety tests, which she failed, and later attempted to administer drug recognition tests. Despite her denial of drug use, Murray admitted to using a vape device earlier that night, although she claimed she did not know what substance it contained.

The Ruling

The court ruled that the evidence presented during the trial was sufficient to support the conviction. Judge Lane stated, "Given [Murray’s] failure to realize that her headlights were off at 1:00 a.m., given her protracted failure to pull over and her brief stop in the middle of that prolonged pursuit, given her confused and disoriented demeanor while interacting with [Officer] Moser, and given her performance on the standardized field sobriety and ARIDE tests, we believe there is no reasonable doubt that [Murray] was under the influence of a drug or combination of drugs that impaired her ability to safely operate a vehicle."

The court emphasized that the Commonwealth did not need to provide a chemical test result to prove impairment. Instead, the totality of the circumstances, including Murray's behavior and the results of the sobriety tests, were sufficient to establish her guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Impact

This ruling reinforces the legal standard for DUI convictions in Pennsylvania, particularly regarding the evidence required to prove impairment. The court's decision clarifies that officers can rely on their observations and the results of field sobriety tests to establish impairment, even in the absence of chemical testing. This case may serve as a reference for future DUI cases, particularly those involving controlled substances.

The ruling also highlights the importance of officer training in recognizing signs of impairment and conducting sobriety tests. The court's affirmation of the trial court's findings suggests that similar cases may result in similar outcomes if the evidence supports the conclusion of impairment.

What's Next

Murray has the option to appeal the ruling to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, should she choose to pursue further legal action. Details regarding any related cases or future actions by the Commonwealth were not available in the court filing.