A Texas appellate court has upheld the conviction of Calvin Wayne Todd, Jr. for sexual assault bigamy, affirming a 30-year prison sentence. The ruling, issued by the Texas Court of Appeals for the Seventh District on November 2, 2026, affects Todd, his family, and the victim, K.M., a minor. This decision underscores the court's commitment to addressing serious crimes against children.

The case originated in February 2021 when Todd and his wife, Ashley, were staying at the home of Jimmy and Crystal Mitchell in Wichita Falls, Texas. The couple was helping with renovations at the Mitchells' residence. On the night of the incident, K.M., the Mitchells' minor daughter, fell asleep between Todd and Ashley while watching television. When she awoke, she reported that Todd had sexually assaulted her.

After the incident, K.M. disclosed the assault to her parents, leading to an investigation. Todd initially denied the allegations but later claimed he thought he was interacting with his wife. A sexual assault nurse examination revealed physical evidence supporting K.M.'s claims, including DNA that could not exclude Todd as a contributor. The jury ultimately found Todd guilty of sexual assault bigamy under Texas Penal Code § 22.011(a)(2), which carries serious penalties, especially when the victim is someone with whom the defendant has a prohibited relationship.

In his appeal, Todd raised three main issues. First, he argued that the trial court erred by not allowing a jury instruction on involuntary conduct, claiming he was unaware of his actions due to intoxication. The court ruled that Todd's defense did not meet the criteria for such an instruction, stating, "A defendant relying on an involuntary conduct defense must admit the offense was committed; Appellant did not do so here." This ruling emphasized that a jury instruction is only warranted if the defendant admits to committing the act.

Secondly, Todd contested the admission of testimony regarding a prior alleged sexual assault involving his ex-wife. He claimed the evidence was irrelevant and prejudicial. The court found that even if the evidence was improperly admitted, it did not significantly influence the jury's verdict due to the strong evidence against Todd, including K.M.'s testimony and physical evidence.

Lastly, Todd challenged the constitutionality of the enhancement under Texas Penal Code § 22.011(f)(1)(A), which elevates sexual assault to a first-degree felony if the victim is someone the defendant is prohibited from marrying. The court noted that Todd failed to preserve this argument for appeal and declined to reconsider established case law on the matter. The ruling stated, "We further note the Court of Criminal Appeals has interpreted section 22.011(f) as essentially requiring proof that the defendant committed sexual assault and that, if he were to marry or claim to marry his victim, then he would be guilty of bigamy."

The court ultimately affirmed the trial court's judgment, solidifying Todd's conviction and sentence. This case highlights the legal system's approach to sexual assault cases, particularly those involving minors, and the importance of upholding convictions in the face of serious allegations.

Moving forward, this ruling may serve as a precedent for similar cases involving sexual assault and the admissibility of evidence regarding prior offenses. It reinforces the legal standards for jury instructions and the handling of sensitive testimony in court. The decision may also impact how future defendants approach their defenses in sexual assault cases.

As of now, it is unclear whether Todd plans to appeal the ruling further. The court filing did not mention any related cases pending or any additional legal actions Todd may pursue. The outcome of this case serves as a reminder of the serious consequences of sexual assault and the legal system's role in addressing such crimes.