The Arkansas Supreme Court recently ruled in favor of the City of Conway, affirming the lower court's decision regarding cleanup liens placed on rental properties owned by Paul Calvert. This ruling, delivered on November 19, 2026, impacts property owners who may face similar enforcement actions from municipalities for code violations.
In this case, Calvert owned several rental properties in Conway. Over the years, the City cited him for multiple violations of local nuisance ordinances, including issues related to trash, broken appliances, and dilapidated structures. After failing to address these violations, the City conducted cleanups and placed liens on three of Calvert’s properties. The court's decision underscores the responsibilities of property owners to maintain their properties and comply with local regulations.
Background
Paul Calvert is a property owner in Conway, Arkansas, who faced multiple nuisance ordinance violations on his rental properties. The City of Conway, represented by Mayor Bart Castleberry and Code Officer Spencer Clawson, took action against Calvert when he failed to rectify these violations. The disputes arose from the City’s enforcement of local ordinances designed to maintain public health and safety.
The City issued notices to Calvert regarding violations at three specific properties: 512 Third Avenue, 1135 Ash Street, and 1900/1902 Dave Ward Drive. After repeated inspections and failed attempts to resolve the issues, the City performed cleanups and subsequently placed liens on the properties to recover cleanup costs. Calvert appealed these liens in the Faulkner County Circuit Court, arguing that the City’s actions were unlawful and violated his due-process rights.
The circuit court dismissed Calvert’s appeals regarding the liens, stating that they were untimely or moot. Calvert then appealed this decision to the Arkansas Supreme Court, seeking to challenge the circuit court's ruling on several grounds, including the legality of the liens and alleged violations of his rights.
The Ruling
The Arkansas Supreme Court affirmed the lower court's decision, stating that Calvert had sufficient notice and opportunity to address the violations before the City imposed the liens. The court noted, "Calvert failed to timely appeal the liens on the Third Avenue and Ash Street properties," and therefore, the circuit court did not have jurisdiction to consider those appeals.
Regarding the lien on the Dave Ward property, the court found that the issue was moot since Calvert sold the property and the lien was paid. The court explained, "Payment of a fine or satisfaction of a judgment generally moots the appeal," indicating that there was no live controversy left to resolve. The court's ruling emphasized the importance of adhering to statutory timelines for appeals and the necessity of providing adequate notice to property owners.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for property owners in Arkansas. It reinforces the authority of municipalities to enforce local ordinances and impose liens for cleanup costs when property owners fail to comply. The decision serves as a reminder that property owners must maintain their properties and respond promptly to municipal notices to avoid legal repercussions.
Furthermore, the court's ruling clarifies the legal standards surrounding the timeliness of appeals and the conditions under which a case may be considered moot. Property owners must be vigilant in understanding their rights and responsibilities under local laws to avoid similar legal challenges.
What's Next
While the Arkansas Supreme Court's decision in this case is final, it is possible that Calvert may seek further legal recourse or challenge other related issues in the future. However, the court's ruling sets a clear precedent regarding the enforcement of municipal liens and property maintenance obligations.
Read Next
Arkansas court rules on custody and asset division in divorce
Arkansas Court Reverses Trust Garnishment Order in Appeal
Arkansas Court Reverses Boundary Dispute Ruling in Favor of Moore
Florida court upholds decision in Medei v. State case
Court rules on constitutionality of Pennsylvania's SORNA II
Court affirms Pennsylvania Parole Board's decision on parole










