The Arkansas Supreme Court recently ruled in favor of Brandye McCue, a former art educator, reversing a decision that denied her unemployment benefits. This ruling is significant as it clarifies the standards for determining misconduct related to unemployment claims, potentially impacting educators and employees across the state.
McCue, who worked for the Strong School District, was denied unemployment benefits after being terminated for failing to supervise a five-year-old student. The court's decision emphasizes the importance of clearly defined misconduct standards in employment law, particularly in cases involving educators.
Background
Brandye McCue was employed as an art teacher in the Strong School District. On November 20, 2024, while escorting a group of students, a five-year-old child left the line to retrieve crayons. McCue did not notice this and continued to the classroom with the other students. The child was later found unharmed in the art classroom by a music educator.
Following this incident, the Strong School District notified McCue of her termination, citing a violation of District Policy 3.27, which mandates that all staff must supervise students diligently. McCue applied for unemployment benefits, but the Arkansas Division of Workforce Services denied her claim, stating that her actions constituted misconduct under Arkansas law.
McCue appealed the decision, and the Arkansas Court of Appeals reversed the Board's ruling, stating that there was insufficient evidence to support the claim of misconduct. The case then reached the Arkansas Supreme Court, which accepted McCue's petition for review to clarify the legal standards governing unemployment benefits.
The Ruling
The Arkansas Supreme Court ruled in favor of McCue, stating that the evidence did not support the Board's conclusion that her conduct amounted to misconduct. The court noted, "the record simply does not establish that she intentionally left the student unattended or willfully disregarded the District’s interest." This ruling reversed the Board's decision and ordered that McCue be awarded unemployment benefits.
The court emphasized the need for substantial evidence to prove that an employee's actions constituted misconduct. The court clarified that a minor lapse in supervision, as was the case with McCue, does not meet the threshold for disqualifying misconduct under Arkansas law. The opinion highlighted that McCue's negligence did not rise to the level of intentional poor performance, which is required for disqualification from benefits.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for employees in Arkansas, particularly those in educational roles. It reinforces the idea that not all lapses in job performance constitute misconduct that would disqualify an employee from receiving unemployment benefits. The court's decision clarifies that negligence alone, without evidence of intent or willful disregard for employer policies, is insufficient for disqualification.
Moreover, this case sets a precedent for future unemployment benefit claims in Arkansas. It underscores the necessity for employers to provide clear evidence of misconduct when denying benefits, particularly in cases involving educators who may face unique challenges in maintaining supervision over young students.
What's Next
Following this ruling, McCue is expected to receive her unemployment benefits. The decision may also prompt the Arkansas Division of Workforce Services to review its procedures for evaluating misconduct claims. There is no indication that this case will be appealed further, and no related cases are currently pending.
Read Next
Arkansas Supreme Court upholds city liens against property owner
Arkansas court rules on custody and asset division in divorce
Arkansas Court Reverses Trust Garnishment Order in Appeal
Court rules on constitutionality of Pennsylvania's SORNA II
Court affirms Pennsylvania Parole Board's decision on parole
Court affirms lien priority in Team 3 Financial case










