The Ohio Court of Appeals has ruled against Donald Knecht, a great-grandfather seeking visitation rights with his two great-granddaughters, Emma and Olivia. The court upheld a lower court's decision that denied Knecht's request, emphasizing the importance of the children's best interests and the wishes of their fit parent. This ruling highlights the complexities of family law and the legal considerations surrounding nonparental visitation rights.

The case, Waymeyer v. Waymeyer (CA2026-01-004), centers around the custody and visitation disputes following the divorce of the children's parents, Michael and Sarah Waymeyer. The court's decision is significant as it sets a precedent for how visitation rights are evaluated in Ohio, particularly in cases involving allegations of abuse and parental fitness.

Background

The parties involved in this case are Michael T. Waymeyer, Sarah Waymeyer, and Donald Knecht. Michael and Sarah married in February 2016 and had two daughters, Emma and Olivia, born in September 2017 and August 2018, respectively. Their marriage faced challenges, leading to a separation in December 2021 after Sarah sought a civil protection order against Michael, which prohibited him from contacting the children.

Following their separation, Sarah began living with Charles Smith, who was later involved in legal issues concerning the children. Michael was granted supervised visitation rights with the children, while Sarah's parenting time was restricted due to concerns about Smith's behavior. The situation escalated with multiple protection orders and allegations of abuse, ultimately leading to a divorce finalized in September 2023.

After the divorce, Knecht sought companionship rights with Emma and Olivia, claiming a desire to maintain a relationship with them. He filed a motion to intervene in the divorce case, which was granted, and a guardian ad litem (GAL) was appointed to assess the situation. A hearing was held in May 2025, where testimony was heard from both Knecht and Michael, along with the GAL's report recommending limited visitation for Knecht.

The Ruling

The Ohio Court of Appeals, led by Judge Piper, affirmed the lower court's decision to deny Knecht's request for companionship time with Emma and Olivia. The court found that Knecht had not met his burden of proving that visitation would be in the children's best interests. The court noted, "The vast majority of cases in which abuse of discretion is asserted involve claims that the decision is unreasonable."

The court emphasized that a fit parent has a fundamental right to make decisions regarding their child's care and that grandparents or great-grandparents do not have a constitutional right to visitation. Instead, they must demonstrate that visitation is in the child's best interest, as outlined in Ohio law. The court found no evidence suggesting that Michael was an unfit parent and that the children were thriving under his care.

The ruling also highlighted concerns about the children's safety and well-being, particularly given Knecht's previous support for Smith during legal proceedings related to allegations of abuse. The court noted that Knecht had minimized the significance of the abuse and expressed skepticism about the allegations, which raised concerns about the potential impact on the children if they were reintroduced to him.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for nonparental visitation rights in Ohio. It underscores the importance of a fit parent's wishes in custody and visitation matters, particularly when there are concerns about the child's safety and well-being. The court's decision reinforces the notion that grandparents or great-grandparents must provide compelling evidence to demonstrate that visitation is in the child's best interests, especially in cases involving allegations of abuse.

The ruling may influence future cases involving nonparental visitation rights, as it establishes a clear standard for how courts should weigh the wishes of fit parents against the desires of extended family members seeking companionship with children. It also emphasizes the need for thorough assessments by guardians ad litem and the importance of considering the child's overall well-being in custody disputes.

What's Next

While Knecht's options for appeal are limited, he may seek to revisit the issue in the future if circumstances change or if new evidence arises. There are currently no related cases pending that could directly impact this ruling. However, this case may serve as a reference point for similar disputes involving nonparental visitation rights in Ohio.