The New York Appellate Division of the Supreme Court has made a significant ruling regarding the disqualification of an attorney representing children in a neglect case. The court ruled on November 18, 2026, in the matter of Yocheved E. (Aron E.), reversing a prior decision that disqualified attorney Tzvi Y. Hagler from representing three children involved in a case initiated by the Rockland County Department of Social Services. This decision highlights the importance of ensuring that children have access to legal representation of their choosing in family court proceedings.
The case stems from allegations of neglect against the children's parents, Aron E. and Lea E., concerning their children Yocheved E., Meir E., and Zev E. The Rockland County Department of Social Services filed the case, claiming that the parents had abused and neglected the children. In July 2024, during the initial court appearance, Hagler identified himself as the privately-retained attorney for the three children. However, the Family Court disqualified him, stating he was not qualified to represent the children because he was not part of the designated panels required for such representation.
The Family Court's decision was based on concerns that the children may not have independently chosen Hagler as their attorney. The court voiced apprehension over potential conflicts of interest, especially since Hagler had spoken to two of the children but not to Yocheved E. The court appointed other attorneys for each child and continued with the proceedings. Hagler subsequently filed a motion to vacate the disqualification, arguing that he had been retained by the children and that no conflict existed. However, the Family Court denied his motion, prompting Hagler to appeal.
In its ruling, the Appellate Division found that the Family Court should have held a hearing to determine whether Hagler was indeed the children's counsel of choice and whether any conflicts of interest existed. The court stated, "Under the circumstances of this case, we find that the court should have held a hearing to determine whether disqualification was warranted." The judges on the panel included Colleen D. Duffy, William G. Ford, Carl J. Landicino, and Elena Goldberg Velazquez.
The Appellate Division emphasized that children in neglect proceedings have a constitutional and statutory right to legal representation. The court noted that the Family Court Act allows minors to choose their own counsel, and it is crucial that the court ensures the attorney is genuinely independent. The ruling also pointed out that the Family Court had failed to adequately investigate the circumstances surrounding Hagler's retention by the children. The court highlighted that there were significant questions about whether Hagler was chosen freely by the children or influenced by outside parties.
The Appellate Division's decision has broader implications for future cases involving children's representation in family court. It underscores the necessity for courts to carefully evaluate whether children have genuinely chosen their legal counsel without undue influence from parents or other parties. The ruling also reinforces the principle that disqualification of an attorney should not occur without substantial evidence and a thorough inquiry.
Moving forward, this ruling sets a precedent that emphasizes the need for hearings in cases where there are questions about the independence of a child's chosen attorney. It also highlights the importance of understanding the dynamics of family relationships in legal proceedings involving children. The Appellate Division reversed the Family Court's order and remitted the matter back to the Family Court for further proceedings consistent with its ruling.
As for what happens next, the Family Court must now conduct a hearing to determine whether Hagler was indeed the counsel of the children's choosing and whether any conflicts of interest exist. The court must ensure that the children's rights to independent legal representation are upheld. The appeal regarding the child Zev E. was dismissed as academic since he has reached the age of majority, but the cases involving Meir E. and Yocheved E. will continue to be examined under this new ruling.
Read Next
Court upholds dismissal of breach of contract claim in Vega case
New York court affirms conviction of Jorge Zavala for child abuse
Court dismisses appeal in Shuo Chang weapon possession case
Illinois court reverses dismissal of postconviction petition
Court Denies Pseudonym for Plaintiff in Doe v. Trump Case
California Court rules on drug testing in juvenile case










