The North Carolina Court of Appeals recently ruled in the case of Victoria M. Cruz v. Jeremiah E. Runkle, allowing a third-party owner to seek the return of firearms surrendered under a domestic violence protective order. The decision, issued on November 18, 2026, affects individuals involved in similar domestic violence cases and clarifies the legal process for recovering seized firearms.
The case began when Victoria Cruz filed a complaint for a domestic violence protective order against Jeremiah Runkle on July 7, 2022. Cruz alleged that Runkle owned several firearms and had permits to purchase and carry them. The trial court issued a temporary ex parte domestic violence protective order, requiring Runkle to surrender his firearms and prohibiting him from purchasing any more. This order expired on December 12, 2022.
In October 2024, Runkle sought the return of his firearms, but the trial court denied his request, citing his previous convictions for assault and driving while impaired. Subsequently, Runkle transferred his firearms to his father, Matthew Runkle, who then filed a motion for the return of the firearms. The trial court denied this motion on August 14, 2025, stating that it was filed too late and that Matthew did not own the firearms at the time they were surrendered.
On appeal, Matthew Runkle challenged the trial court's decision, arguing that the timing of his motion should not bar recovery and that he could still obtain the firearms despite not owning them at the time of their surrender. The North Carolina Court of Appeals, led by Judge Jefferson Griffin, examined the relevant laws and the circumstances surrounding the case.
The court ruled that the timing of Matthew Runkle's motion did not operate as a mandatory bar to recovery. The court noted that North Carolina General Statute section 50B-3.1(g) had been amended in February 2026, eliminating the previous thirty-day time limit for filing such motions. The court stated, "We hold that the timing of Mr. Runkle’s motion does not operate as a mandatory bar to recovery." This change in the law allowed Matthew Runkle to file his motion without being restricted by the previous deadline.
Additionally, the court addressed the issue of whether a third party could recover firearms that they did not own at the time of seizure. The court found that the trial court had erred in its reasoning, stating that the law did not prohibit a defendant from transferring ownership of firearms to a third party, even if they were in the possession of law enforcement due to a protective order. The court emphasized that "the fact that Mr. Runkle did not own the firearms on the date of seizure does not prohibit him from recovering them."
The ruling clarifies that individuals who have surrendered firearms under a domestic violence protective order may transfer ownership to a third party, and that the new law allows for motions to recover firearms to be filed at any time before disposal. This decision could have significant implications for individuals involved in domestic violence cases, as it reinforces the rights of third-party owners and clarifies the legal process for recovering seized firearms.
The court's decision also highlighted the importance of statutory amendments in ongoing cases. The court noted that when a law changes while a case is pending, the new law must be applied. This principle ensures that individuals are not unfairly penalized by outdated legal standards.
As a result of this ruling, Matthew Runkle's motion for the return of the firearms has been vacated and remanded, meaning the trial court must reconsider the motion in light of the appellate court's findings. This decision may encourage other individuals in similar situations to seek the return of their firearms and could lead to further legal clarifications regarding the ownership and recovery of firearms in domestic violence cases.
The outcome of Cruz v. Runkle is significant for the legal landscape surrounding domestic violence protective orders and firearm rights in North Carolina. It sets a precedent for third-party claims to recover firearms and emphasizes the importance of legislative changes in ongoing legal matters.
Looking ahead, it remains to be seen whether the trial court will grant Matthew Runkle's motion upon remand. Additionally, the case may prompt further discussions about the rights of firearm owners in domestic violence situations and the legal processes involved in recovering seized property.
Read Next
Court upholds conviction of Lamont Barrino for firearm possession
Court affirms summary judgment in Bratcher Adams case
Court affirms dismissal of Lozada's appeal in ejectment case
Court affirms sentence for Aaron Bressi in contempt case
California Court of Appeal Rules on Shields Divorce Case
California Court reverses juvenile court dismissal of cases










