The New York Supreme Court in Rockland County has scheduled a hearing to determine the status of a manufactured home claimed abandoned by Parkway MHC, LLC, affecting resident Mark Alfieri. The court's decision, set for December 16, 2026, will address whether the home, located at 156 Parkway Trailer Court in Pomona, has indeed been abandoned and what rights each party holds regarding the property.

This case stems from a dispute between Parkway MHC, LLC, the owner of the manufactured home park, and Mark Alfieri, a former resident who leased a lot in the park. The court's ruling will have significant implications for both parties, particularly for Alfieri, who asserts he still has rights to the home despite being evicted in June 2025.

Background

Parkway MHC, LLC operates the manufactured home park where Alfieri leased a lot and owned a manufactured home. The dispute began when Parkway MHC alleged that Alfieri had violated his lease agreement, leading to a previous eviction process. After a series of legal proceedings, including a prior petition that was dismissed without prejudice, Parkway MHC filed a new petition on July 21, 2026, seeking a declaration that the home was abandoned.

The petitioner claims that Alfieri has not made any rent payments since May 2025 and that the home has been vacant since his eviction. They also allege that utility services to the home have been terminated for over 60 days, and much of Alfieri's personal property has been removed. However, Alfieri contests these claims, stating he was not allowed to retrieve his belongings and wishes to sell the home.

The Ruling

Judge John P. Collins Jr. presided over the case and ruled that the issues presented required a hearing. The court noted that Parkway MHC had not provided sufficient proof that the home had been abandoned under the relevant laws. The court stated, "Petitioner has not established that it caused the search required by RPAPL 792 (3) to be made before commencing this proceeding or that it has notified all known lienholders." This ruling indicates that the court found gaps in the petitioner's claims regarding the abandonment of the home.

Judge Collins further emphasized that several factual disputes remain unresolved, which necessitates a hearing to determine the facts surrounding the case. The court has scheduled this hearing for December 16, 2026, to address specific issues, including the home’s date of manufacture and whether the necessary legal procedures were followed regarding lienholders.

Impact

The upcoming hearing will significantly affect both parties involved. For Parkway MHC, a ruling in their favor could allow them to take possession of the home and potentially sell or dispose of it as they see fit. Conversely, if the court finds in favor of Alfieri, he may retain ownership rights and have the opportunity to repair and sell the home.

This case highlights the complexities surrounding the abandonment of manufactured homes and the legal protections afforded to residents. The outcome could set a precedent for similar cases in New York, particularly regarding the necessary steps landlords must take to establish abandonment and the rights of tenants in such situations.

What's Next

The case is set for a hearing on December 16, 2026, where both parties will present evidence. The court will determine whether the home has been abandoned and what legal rights each party holds. Depending on the outcome, there may be further appeals or related cases as the parties seek to resolve their disputes.