The Iowa Court of Appeals has affirmed a decision to modify child custody, placing two children in the physical care of their father, Colton Jon Van Surksum. The ruling came in response to concerns about domestic violence and instability in the home of their mother, Abbie Joleen Van Otterloo, formerly known as Abbie Joleen Glaser. This decision affects the custody arrangement for the children and highlights the court's focus on their best interests.

The case, identified as No. 25-2113, originated in the Iowa District Court for Sioux County and was decided on November 18, 2026. The court ruled that the environment in which the children were living with Abbie was detrimental due to her relationship with her paramour, Raymond Glaser, who has a history of criminal behavior, including domestic violence. This ruling underscores the court's priority of child safety and welfare in custody disputes.

Colton and Abbie share two children, born in 2015 and 2017, respectively. Although Colton is not the legal father of Abbie's oldest child, he has acted as a father figure to all three children. The couple separated in 2019, and for several years, Colton had primary care of the children. Following their separation, Abbie entered a tumultuous relationship with Ray, which raised significant concerns about the children's safety.

In late 2022, Colton filed a petition to establish paternity and custody after observing troubling behavior in the children, which he attributed to Ray's presence in their lives. Abbie and Ray's relationship was marked by instability and allegations of domestic violence, prompting Colton to seek a modification of the custody arrangement. The situation escalated when Colton's wife called the sheriff's office for a welfare check on the children after hearing alarming statements from the oldest child.

During the trial, the court heard testimonies from both parents and evaluated evidence regarding Ray's past behavior. While Abbie defended Ray, claiming he had a positive influence on the children, the court found her testimony lacking credibility. The court noted that Colton had presented substantial evidence of Ray's abusive history and its negative impact on the children.

The court ultimately ruled that Colton had established a substantial change in circumstances, which warranted a modification of the custody order. The judge stated, "The negative environment in Abbie’s home due to Ray’s presence and actions... diminishes Abbie’s ability to adequately parent the children." This statement reflects the court's determination that Colton could provide a safer and more stable environment for the children.

In affirming the district court's decision, the Iowa Court of Appeals emphasized that the children's best interests must be the primary consideration in custody cases. The court recognized that while there is a strong preference for keeping siblings together, this presumption can be overridden when the circumstances warrant it, as was the case here.

The ruling also addressed concerns about the significant reduction in Abbie's parenting time, which she argued was contrary to the children's best interests. However, the court found that contact with Abbie would also mean contact with Ray, which posed a risk to the children's welfare. The court concluded that limiting Abbie's parenting time was justified given the circumstances.

This ruling has significant implications for custody cases in Iowa, particularly those involving allegations of domestic violence. It reinforces the idea that the court will prioritize the safety and well-being of children over maintaining existing custody arrangements, especially in cases where a parent's relationship poses a risk to the children.

Looking ahead, Abbie has the option to appeal this decision, but details regarding any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. The case highlights the ongoing challenges faced by parents in custody disputes, particularly when issues of domestic violence and child safety are involved.