The Iowa Court of Appeals has affirmed a lower court's decision to modify child custody, placing two children in the physical care of their father, Colton Jon Van Surksum. This ruling comes after concerns were raised about the children's exposure to domestic violence and instability in their mother's home, where her new partner has a criminal history. The case, Colton Jon Van Surksum v. Abbie Joleen Van Otterloo f/k/a Abbie Joleen Glaser, was filed under docket number 25-2113 on November 18, 2026.

The court's decision affects the lives of Abbie Joleen Van Otterloo and her children, as it changes their living arrangements and raises questions about their safety and well-being. The ruling underscores the importance of a stable and safe environment for children, particularly in cases involving domestic violence.

Background

Colton Van Surksum and Abbie Van Otterloo share two children, born in 2015 and 2017. Colton is the legal father of the youngest child, while he considers Abbie's oldest child his daughter as well. The couple separated in 2019, after which Abbie entered a relationship with Raymond Glaser, who has a significant criminal history, including convictions for domestic abuse.

In late 2022, Colton petitioned for paternity and custody, seeking to establish a more stable environment for the children. Initially, a child and family reporter recommended that Abbie retain physical care of the children, but this recommendation changed as evidence of Ray's presence and the potential dangers he posed to the children surfaced. Colton's concerns grew when he learned that Ray was living with Abbie and that the children were exposed to a negative environment.

The Ruling

The Iowa Court of Appeals upheld the district court's decision to grant Colton physical custody of the children. The court found that Abbie's relationship with Ray constituted a substantial change in circumstances that warranted a modification of custody. The opinion stated, "The children’s best interest is the controlling consideration," emphasizing that the court must prioritize their safety and well-being.

The court noted that Abbie's choices put her children's welfare at risk, stating, "the negative environment in Abbie’s home due to Ray’s presence and actions... diminishes Abbie’s ability to adequately parent the children." The judges involved in this ruling included Greer, P.J., Buller, and Langholz, with Buller writing the opinion.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for child custody cases in Iowa, particularly those involving allegations of domestic violence. It reinforces the notion that a parent's relationship with an individual who poses a risk to the children can impact custody decisions. The court's emphasis on the children's best interests serves as a reminder that the safety and stability of the home environment are critical factors in custody determinations.

Furthermore, the decision may influence future cases where one parent raises concerns about the other parent's partner. It establishes a precedent that courts will consider the broader context of a parent's living situation and the potential risks associated with it when making custody decisions.

What's Next

While the court has affirmed the custody ruling, it is unclear if Abbie plans to appeal the decision. The court filing did not indicate any related cases pending at this time. The outcome of this case may prompt further discussions about child safety and custody arrangements in similar situations.