A Texas appellate court has upheld the dismissal of a lawsuit filed by Vicker Sichanthavong against the City of Amarillo and its Building Official, Johnny Scholl. The court ruled that Sichanthavong's claims regarding the denial of a plumbing permit were not sufficient to establish jurisdiction. This decision affects Sichanthavong, who alleged discrimination and violations of federal law in his bid to obtain a plumbing permit for his construction projects.
The case, Vicker Sichanthavong v. Johnny Scholl, was filed in the Texas Court of Appeals, 7th District (Docket No. 07-26-00294-CV) on November 16, 2026. The court's ruling is significant as it addresses issues related to governmental immunity and the requirements for bringing claims against public officials.
Background
Sichanthavong's legal troubles began in 2019 when he sought a plumbing permit to build homes at two different locations. He claimed he did not have the funds to pay for the permits at that time and hoped to secure them by 2020. However, he alleged that the City of Amarillo halted operations due to the COVID-19 pandemic, which the City disputes. In October 2023, he claimed he was offered a building permit but was informed that he needed to hire a licensed plumber for the plumbing work.
After being denied a plumbing permit, Sichanthavong filed a lawsuit against Scholl in his official capacity. He claimed that the City and Scholl violated several federal laws, including 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and the Fair Housing Act. He also challenged the validity of the City ordinance that governed plumbing permits, arguing that it was unconstitutional and discriminatory. Throughout the legal process, he submitted multiple amended pleadings, with his fifth amended petition being the most recent.
The Ruling
The Texas Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the City of Amarillo, affirming the trial court's decision to dismiss Sichanthavong's claims. The court noted that Sichanthavong failed to demonstrate that the City had waived its sovereign immunity, which protects governmental entities from lawsuits unless specific conditions are met. The court stated, "Sichanthavong did not argue waiver of immunity or present any evidence to support waiver. Thus, the trial court properly found the City had not waived sovereign immunity and did not err in granting the City’s plea dismissing Sichanthavong’s claims."
Furthermore, the court addressed Sichanthavong's claim under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, explaining that such claims could be raised in state court only if the parties and controversy were properly before the court. The court pointed out that because Sichanthavong sued Scholl in his official capacity, it was effectively a suit against the City, which is not considered a 'person' under section 1983. Therefore, his claim was not legally valid.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for future claims against governmental entities in Texas. It reinforces the principle of sovereign immunity, making it clear that individuals must adequately plead facts that demonstrate a waiver of this immunity when suing a governmental unit. The court's decision also highlights the importance of properly framing legal claims, especially when alleging violations of federal laws like the Fair Housing Act or 42 U.S.C. § 1983.
For Sichanthavong, the court's ruling effectively ends his legal battle over the plumbing permit. The decision underscores the challenges individuals may face when navigating the legal system, particularly when representing themselves, as Sichanthavong did in this case.
What's Next
While the court's decision is final in this case, Sichanthavong may seek further legal recourse, although the likelihood of success appears limited given the court's clear ruling on the issues presented. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases or potential appeals.
Read Next
Texas Court upholds conviction in child sexual abuse case
Texas Court denies Senrick Wilkerson's writ of mandamus
Texas Court Denies James Yu's Request for Mandamus Relief
Arkansas Attorney General clarifies airport commission's powers
Ohio Court affirms domestic violence protection order ruling
Court upholds default judgments against Nikole Harrington










