The Third District Court of Appeal in Florida has ruled on a significant foreclosure case involving Shenker Group, LLC and HMC Assets, LLC. The court affirmed a lower court's decision that Shenker Group waived its defense of usury due to a settlement agreement made in an earlier foreclosure action. This ruling, filed on November 18, 2026, affects the parties involved and highlights the importance of settlement agreements in legal disputes.
The case, identified by docket number 3D25-1383, arose from a foreclosure action initiated by HMC Assets against Shenker Group. The court's decision underscores the legal principle that parties are bound by the terms of their agreements, particularly in settlement contexts.
Background
The dispute began in 2019 when HMC Assets, LLC, acting as a trustee, filed a foreclosure action against Shenker Group, LLC. In response, Shenker Group asserted usury as an affirmative defense, claiming that the interest rates involved in the loan were excessively high and illegal under Florida law. However, during the litigation, the parties reached a settlement agreement and a loan modification agreement.
This settlement agreement included a broad release clause in which Shenker Group discharged HMC Assets from any claims related to the loan and the foreclosure action. Specifically, the agreement stated that Shenker Group released HMC Assets from “any and all claims, demands, damages, debts, liabilities, obligations, contracts, agreements, causes of action, suits and costs, of whatever nature.” This release covered both known and unknown claims, including any defenses that could have been asserted in the foreclosure action.
Years later, after defaulting on the loan, Shenker Group faced a new foreclosure action initiated by HMC Assets. Once again, Shenker Group attempted to assert the usury defense. HMC Assets responded by filing a motion for summary judgment, arguing that Shenker Group had waived this defense through the earlier settlement agreement. The trial court agreed and ruled in favor of HMC Assets, leading to the appeal by Shenker Group.
The Ruling
The Third District Court of Appeal reviewed the case and affirmed the trial court's decision. The court emphasized that Shenker Group was bound by the terms of the settlement agreement, which explicitly released HMC Assets from any claims related to the loan and foreclosure action. The ruling stated, "Turning to the text of the settlement agreement, Shenker Group released and discharged 'any and all claims' it 'may have or may hereafter have or claim to have' 'arising out of or in connection with the Loan, Property, Foreclosure Action, and Counterclaim.'"
The court further noted that the release included all defenses asserted in the foreclosure action or that could have been asserted, which encompassed Shenker Group’s usury defense. The judges on the panel, identified as LOBREE, BOKOR, and GOODEN, concluded that the settlement agreement was clear and enforceable, stating, "Because Shenker Group is bound by the terms of the settlement agreement, we affirm in all respects." This ruling reinforces the principle that courts will uphold the intentions of parties as expressed in their contractual agreements.
Impact
The court's ruling has significant implications for Shenker Group and HMC Assets. For Shenker Group, the decision means that it cannot rely on the usury defense in the current foreclosure action, potentially leading to a loss of property. This case serves as a reminder to all parties involved in legal disputes about the importance of understanding the implications of settlement agreements. Once a settlement is reached, it can limit future claims and defenses.
Moreover, this ruling sets a precedent for similar cases in Florida. It reinforces the idea that courts will not interfere with the freedom of contract and will uphold the terms agreed upon by the parties. This could discourage parties from attempting to revive claims or defenses that have been waived in previous settlements, thereby promoting finality in legal disputes.
What's Next
Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether Shenker Group plans to appeal the ruling. However, the court's decision is currently final unless a timely motion for rehearing is filed. There are no related cases pending that were mentioned in the opinion.
Read Next
Court reverses dismissal of privacy complaint against 5 Star Nutrition
Florida Court Affirms Eviction Judgment Against Tenant
Florida court affirms decision in Kelsey v. State of Florida
Oregon Court of Appeals rules on attorney fees in business case
Oregon court upholds cancellation of marijuana producer license
Ninth Circuit Reverses Driver Provider Ruling on Wage Claims










