The Tennessee Court of Appeals has upheld a ruling against Off the Wagon Tours, LLC, and its owner, Charles Curtis Carney, for operating unlicensed entertainment transportation vehicles (ETVs) in Nashville. The court affirmed the trial court's findings of criminal contempt and denied the company's appeal regarding an injunction that prohibited its operations. This decision affects local businesses that operate under Nashville's entertainment transportation regulations.
The dispute began when the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County (Metro Nashville) filed a civil warrant against Off the Wagon for continuing to operate its ETVs without the required permits. The trial court had previously issued a temporary injunction to stop Off the Wagon from violating the city's ordinances, which were enacted to regulate passenger transportation services. The court's ruling is significant as it reinforces the authority of local governments to enforce regulations on businesses operating within their jurisdictions.
Background
Off the Wagon Tours, LLC, known for its Nashville Party Wagon service, provides entertainment transportation for tourists. Under Tennessee law, metropolitan governments have the authority to regulate transportation services, including ETVs, which were defined and regulated under the Tennessee Passenger Transportation Services Act. In 2022, the state extended this authority to include ETVs, requiring operators to obtain permits.
Despite being aware of the permit application deadline set by the Metropolitan Transportation Licensing Commission, Off the Wagon failed to submit its application on time and continued to operate. As a result, Metro Nashville issued over 30 citations for operating without the necessary permits. When the company continued its operations, Metro Nashville sought a civil warrant in court to enforce compliance and prevent further violations.
The case was moved to circuit court, where Metro Nashville requested both temporary and permanent injunctions against Off the Wagon. The trial court granted a temporary injunction, concluding that the relevant ordinances were valid and enforceable. However, Off the Wagon continued to operate, leading Metro Nashville to file for criminal contempt against the company and its owner.
The Ruling
The Tennessee Court of Appeals ruled that it lacked subject matter jurisdiction to review the injunction but affirmed the trial court's findings of criminal contempt. Judge W. Neal McBrayer, writing for the court, stated, "The order in which the trial court entered the permanent injunction does not dispose of all claims against a party, so the issue is whether the order resolves an entire claim."
The court noted that while Off the Wagon raised several arguments against the legality of the injunction, including claims that Metro Nashville lacked authority to seek it, the court found that the trial court had jurisdiction over the matter. The court emphasized that an order imposing punishment for contempt is a final appealable order, even if the underlying proceedings are ongoing.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for businesses operating in Nashville and other metropolitan areas in Tennessee. It reinforces the power of local governments to regulate transportation services and hold businesses accountable for compliance with local ordinances. The decision underscores the importance of obtaining the necessary permits and adhering to regulations to avoid legal consequences.
Moreover, the ruling clarifies the legal standards for contempt findings in cases involving violations of court orders. It establishes that even if a party believes an injunction is erroneous, they are still required to comply with it while it remains in effect. This precedent may influence future cases involving local business regulations and compliance with municipal ordinances.
What's Next
Off the Wagon Tours has the option to appeal the ruling, but the court has already affirmed the contempt findings. The case is now remanded to the trial court for further proceedings regarding any potential damages or penalties. Details were not available in the court filing regarding any related cases or further actions by Metro Nashville.
Read Next
Tennessee Court Upholds Summary Judgment in UM Case
Tennessee court affirms ruling on child dependency case
Tennessee Supreme Court clarifies liquidated damages rules
Court vacates ruling in Promier Products false advertising case
Court affirms insurance coverage for United Rentals claims
Ohio Court Rules on Golf Cart Rental Fee Dispute










