The Tennessee Supreme Court recently clarified the state’s standard for determining whether a contractual provision for damages should be enforced as liquidated damages or deemed a penalty. This decision, from the case SH Nashville, LLC v. FWREF Nashville Airport, LLC (docket number M2023-01147-SC-R11-CV), has significant implications for businesses and individuals involved in contractual agreements in the state.

The court ruled that when parties to a contract agree that actual damages would be difficult to ascertain and that their agreed-upon liquidated sum is a reasonable estimate of damages, there is a presumption that the provision is enforceable as liquidated damages. The ruling affects how future contracts are interpreted, especially in cases involving real estate and other business transactions.

Background

The dispute in this case arose from a purchase and sale agreement made in October 2019 between FWREF Nashville Airport, LLC (the Seller) and UNI Nashville Airport Hotel, LLC (the Purchaser) for a Hilton-branded hotel near Nashville Airport. The agreement included a provision stating that if the Purchaser failed to perform its obligations, the Seller would be entitled to retain the earnest money as liquidated damages. The initial purchase price was set at $79 million, with an earnest money deposit of $1.75 million.

Over the following months, the parties executed 24 amendments to the agreement, which included various adjustments to the purchase price and earnest money deposits. However, complications arose when the Purchaser learned of a new Hilton hotel set to open nearby, leading to concerns about profitability. Ultimately, the Purchaser failed to close the sale by the agreed date, prompting the Seller to terminate the agreement and retain the earnest money.

The Purchaser filed a lawsuit in April 2022, seeking a declaratory judgment that the Seller’s retention of the earnest money was an unenforceable penalty. The case was transferred to the Davidson County Business Court, where the trial court ruled in favor of the Seller. However, the Court of Appeals reversed the decision, leading to the Supreme Court’s involvement.

The Ruling

The Tennessee Supreme Court ruled that the provision in question should be enforced as liquidated damages. Justice Dwight E. Tarwater delivered the opinion, stating that “when the parties to a contract expressly agree that actual damages would be difficult or impossible to ascertain and that their agreed-upon liquidated sum is a reasonable estimate of damages, there is a presumption that the provision is enforceable as liquidated damages.”

The court emphasized that to overcome this presumption, the party seeking to avoid enforcement must demonstrate, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the provision is actually an unenforceable penalty. In this case, the Purchaser did not provide sufficient evidence to challenge the enforceability of the provision.

Impact

This ruling has significant implications for future contractual agreements in Tennessee. It sets a clear standard for how liquidated damages provisions will be treated, reinforcing the presumption of enforceability when both parties agree that actual damages are hard to determine. This decision may encourage parties to include more liquidated damages clauses in their contracts, knowing that such provisions will likely be upheld as long as they meet the outlined criteria.

Additionally, the ruling underscores the importance of clear communication and documentation in contracts. Parties must ensure that their agreements explicitly state the reasons for liquidated damages and that they are based on reasonable estimates of potential damages. This clarity will help avoid disputes and litigation over the enforceability of such provisions in the future.

What's Next

The case has been remanded to the Chancery Court for further proceedings consistent with the Supreme Court's opinion. It remains to be seen whether the Purchaser will pursue additional claims or if the parties will reach a settlement.