A New Jersey appellate court has reversed a lower court's ruling that barred expert testimony in a case involving a longshoreman injured while working on a cargo vessel. The decision, issued on November 19, 2026, allows the case to proceed, impacting the parties involved and potentially influencing future cases regarding maritime safety standards.

The case, Rishi A. Ramlochan v. Evergreen Shipping Agency (Docket No. A-2795-24), centers around Rishi A. Ramlochan, a longshoreman who alleges he was injured due to unsafe practices involving a gangway on the MV EVER LUCID, a vessel owned by Evergreen Marine Corporation (Taiwan), Ltd. The court's ruling is significant as it addresses the admissibility of expert testimony in personal injury cases, particularly in maritime contexts.

In the original complaint, Ramlochan claimed he was injured on December 14, 2018, while attempting to descend a gangway that had been improperly positioned on a cap log, a piece of wood that elevated the gangway above the dock. He argued that the defendants, Evergreen Shipping Agency and Evergreen Marine Corporation, breached their duty of care under the Longshore and Harbor Workers' Compensation Act (LHWCA) by failing to ensure a safe working environment.

Ramlochan's legal team presented an expert report from Captain Joseph Ahlstrom, who asserted that the gangway's placement was unsafe and contributed to the injury. However, the lower court barred Ahlstrom's testimony, determining it constituted a 'net opinion'—a conclusion without sufficient factual support. This ruling led to a summary judgment in favor of the defendants.

The appellate court, however, found that the lower court misapplied its discretion in excluding Ahlstrom's expert testimony. The judges noted that Ahlstrom's extensive maritime experience and his reliance on established safety standards provided a solid foundation for his opinions. The court stated, "The Captain relied upon the ISM and SOLAS codes to establish defendants had a duty to provide a safe environment, which included a safe gangway."

The court highlighted that Ahlstrom's report detailed how the gangway's unsafe positioning directly contributed to Ramlochan's injuries. The judges emphasized that factual disputes about the gangway's placement and the knowledge of the plaintiff should be resolved by a jury, not through summary judgment.

The ruling also clarified the standards for admitting expert testimony in New Jersey courts. The appellate court reiterated that expert opinions must be grounded in factual evidence and that the net opinion rule does not preclude experts from drawing conclusions based on their experience and the facts presented.

The court's decision to reverse the summary judgment means that Ramlochan's case will proceed to trial, where the jury will hear Ahlstrom's testimony and evaluate the evidence regarding the safety practices on the vessel. This ruling is expected to have broader implications for similar injury cases in maritime law, particularly regarding the standards of care owed to longshoremen and the admissibility of expert testimony.

Moving forward, the outcome of this case could influence how maritime safety standards are interpreted and enforced, particularly in relation to the responsibilities of vessel owners and operators. The court's decision reinforces the importance of expert testimony in establishing the standard of care in personal injury cases, particularly those involving complex maritime operations.

As for what’s next, the case will return to the lower court for further proceedings consistent with the appellate court's ruling. There is currently no indication that the defendants will appeal this decision, but they may seek to challenge Ahlstrom's testimony during the trial. The legal teams for both sides are preparing for the next steps in what promises to be a significant trial regarding workplace safety in maritime settings.