A New Jersey court has upheld the conviction of Mark Sher, who was found guilty of multiple motor vehicle offenses after an incident involving a school bus. The ruling, made by the New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division on November 19, 2026, affects Sher and highlights the legal standards surrounding traffic violations and witness testimony.
The case arose from an incident on February 25, 2022, when Sher followed a school bus that had failed to pick up his daughter. He was convicted of four motor vehicle offenses and two disorderly persons offenses. The court's decision is significant as it addresses the admissibility of witness testimony and the standards of evidence in traffic violation cases.
Background
The parties involved in this case are the State of New Jersey, represented by Middlesex County Prosecutor Linda Estremera, and Mark Sher, the defendant. The dispute centers on Sher's actions after he believed the school bus assigned to transport his daughter had passed her stop without picking her up. Following the incident, the school district's senior transportation manager, Joyce Forsberg, filed complaints against Sher for various traffic violations.
The case was initially tried in a municipal court, where Sher was found guilty. He appealed to the Law Division, which conducted a trial de novo, meaning it reviewed the case anew. The appeal was prompted by concerns over the admission of testimony from Forsberg and Detective Brian Adams, who were not sworn in before testifying in the municipal court.
The Ruling
The New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division affirmed the convictions, rejecting Sher's arguments regarding the admission of unsworn testimony. The court ruled that the failure to administer an oath to Forsberg and Adams did not warrant reversal of the conviction. The judges noted, "the oath defect does not warrant reversal, and the Law Division's findings are supported by sufficient credible evidence."
The ruling emphasized that Sher had waived his right to contest the unsworn testimony by not raising the issue during the municipal court proceedings. The judges highlighted that the video evidence and the sworn testimony of the bus driver, Audrey Maxwell, were sufficient to support the conviction. Judge Robert J. Jones, Jr. presided over the Law Division trial and found the evidence credible, concluding that Sher's actions constituted violations of traffic laws.
Impact
This ruling reinforces the importance of proper legal procedures in traffic violation cases, especially regarding witness testimony. It clarifies that failing to raise procedural issues in lower courts can lead to waiving those rights on appeal. The court's reliance on video evidence and the credibility of sworn witnesses underlines the significance of objective evidence in legal determinations.
The decision may also serve as a precedent for future cases involving traffic violations and the admissibility of witness testimony. It highlights that even if procedural errors occur, they may not necessarily lead to a reversal of convictions if sufficient evidence supports the ruling.
What's Next
Details were not available in the court filing regarding whether Sher plans to appeal this decision further. However, the ruling stands as a significant legal precedent in New Jersey's traffic law enforcement.
Read Next
Texas Court denies Timothy Lee's petition for mandamus relief
New Jersey Supreme Court Rules on Bridge Sign Liability Case
Florida court affirms ruling in Khadene Pitter case
Illinois Supreme Court rules on pretrial release petition timing
Florida court affirms decision in Barry Carrell case
Court affirms ruling in Alexander v. City of Stuart case










