The Washington Supreme Court ruled on November 19, 2026, in the case of State v. Amsden, No. 104521-2, clarifying important issues related to sentencing and prior convictions. The decision affects how courts handle the presentation of criminal history during sentencing, particularly in cases involving domestic violence. This ruling is significant for defendants facing similar circumstances in Washington state.
Walter Amsden was convicted of violating a no contact order, which is a serious offense when it involves an intimate partner. The case arose after Amsden was found guilty by a jury, but issues emerged during sentencing regarding the proof of his prior convictions. The State had claimed that Amsden had prior convictions that should affect his sentencing, but the court found that the State did not adequately prove these prior convictions during the initial sentencing.
The Washington Court of Appeals reviewed Amsden's case and agreed that the State had not proven the existence of all prior convictions necessary for calculating his offender score. The appellate court affirmed Amsden's conviction but reversed the sentence and remanded the case for resentencing. The court allowed the State to present additional evidence regarding Amsden's criminal history, which led to the Supreme Court's involvement.
The Supreme Court was asked to determine whether the Court of Appeals' decision to allow the State to present additional evidence conflicted with a previous ruling in Erlinger v. United States, which established that certain facts affecting a defendant's punishment must be determined by a jury. Amsden contended that the remand violated this principle because it required the sentencing court to make factual findings about his prior convictions, including whether they had 'washed out' or if they were comparable to Washington offenses.
The court ruled that the principles established in Erlinger do apply to Washington's Sentencing Reform Act, but they do not apply to washout determinations. The court stated, "Erlinger does not apply to washout determinations because washout determinations do not increase a defendant’s punishment or penalty." This means that the court can determine whether a conviction has washed out without requiring a jury to make that finding.
Additionally, the court addressed the issue of domestic violence designations. It clarified that if domestic violence was pleaded and proven to a jury in prior convictions, then it does not violate Erlinger for the sentencing court to consider those designations. The court emphasized that these designations do not alter the underlying offense but can impact sentencing.
The ruling has important implications for future cases. It clarifies that while certain facts about a defendant's criminal history must be determined by a jury, others, like whether a conviction has washed out, can be determined by the court. This distinction helps streamline the sentencing process while still protecting defendants' rights. The decision also reinforces the importance of jury findings in cases involving domestic violence.
Moving forward, this ruling may affect how courts handle similar cases involving prior convictions and domestic violence designations in Washington state. Defendants in similar situations should be aware of this ruling as it could impact their sentencing outcomes.
As for what’s next, Amsden's case will be sent back to the lower court for resentencing, where the State will be allowed to present additional evidence regarding his prior convictions. There is no indication in the ruling that Amsden plans to appeal further, but the legal landscape surrounding sentencing in Washington has been shaped by this decision.
Read Next
New Jersey court upholds conviction of Mark Sher in bus case
Texas Court Orders Transfer of Child Custody Case Venue
Texas Court affirms termination of parental rights in appeal
Texas Court dismisses Ali Choudhri's mandamus petition
Texas Court dismisses appeal over marriage date dispute
Texas Court denies Timothy Lee's petition for mandamus relief









