The Washington Supreme Court recently ruled that state safety inspectors did not violate any laws when they entered a fitness center to seek consent for an inspection. This decision affects businesses across the state, particularly those operating under safety regulations during emergencies like the COVID-19 pandemic.

The case, Bradshaw Development, Inc. v. Department of Labor and Industries, No. 104579-4, arose after inspectors entered Anytime Fitness in Selah, Washington, to investigate claims that the gym was operating in violation of COVID-19 safety regulations. The ruling clarifies the authority of inspectors under state law and addresses constitutional privacy concerns.

In June 2020, Governor Jay Inslee issued a proclamation that temporarily closed gyms and fitness centers to limit the spread of COVID-19. Following this, the Washington State Department of Labor and Industries (L&I) received complaints that Bradshaw Development, which operates Anytime Fitness, was still open. L&I inspectors visited the facility to verify these claims. Upon arrival, they noticed the gym's neon 'open' sign but found the doors were accessible only to key card holders.

After unsuccessfully attempting to contact someone inside, the inspectors followed a customer into the gym. Inside, they observed multiple people exercising and interacting with staff. When they asked for permission to conduct an inspection, the gym's management denied their request. Subsequently, L&I cited Bradshaw Development for violating workplace safety regulations and imposed a penalty of $9,639.

Bradshaw Development challenged the citation in Yakima County Superior Court, which initially agreed that the inspectors had the right to enter the gym but ruled that their observations inside were inadmissible. The court argued that the gym's key card access indicated a reasonable expectation of privacy. The State appealed this decision.

The Washington Supreme Court ultimately reversed the lower court's ruling, stating that the inspectors' entry did not violate the relevant state statute or the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. The court emphasized that the inspectors were permitted to enter the gym to seek consent for an inspection and that the front entrance was a 'reasonably recognizable entry point.' The court stated, 'The inspectors’ entry did not violate the statute.' Furthermore, it concluded that Bradshaw Development did not demonstrate a reasonable expectation of privacy in the gym's front entrance area.

Judge González, writing for the court, noted that the gym's illuminated 'open' sign and the lack of evidence showing a strict policy against non-member entry suggested that the business impliedly invited the public inside for legitimate inquiries. The court ruled, 'A government inspector does not conduct a search simply by occupying a space they were impliedly invited to enter.'

This ruling has significant implications for businesses operating in Washington, especially those that may be subject to safety inspections during emergencies. It clarifies that inspectors can enter commercial premises to seek consent without violating privacy rights, provided they do not exceed their scope of entry. This decision may also influence how businesses implement access policies, particularly in emergency situations.

The Washington Supreme Court's ruling may set a precedent for future cases involving workplace safety inspections and privacy rights. It reinforces the idea that businesses must take appropriate measures to restrict public access if they wish to maintain privacy in certain areas.

Looking ahead, Bradshaw Development may seek further legal recourse, but details on any potential appeals were not available in the court filing. The outcome of this case could influence similar disputes across the state as businesses navigate compliance with safety regulations.