The Washington Court of Appeals recently ruled on a case involving the Washington State Attorney General’s Office and the Puyallup Tribe of Indians against the Washington Utilities and Transportation Commission (WUTC) and Puget Sound Energy (PSE). The court's decision, filed on November 17, 2026, affects the rates that PSE can charge its customers to recover costs associated with the construction of the Tacoma Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) Facility.
This ruling is significant because it addresses the financial implications of utility projects on consumers, particularly in light of environmental and public interest considerations. The outcome of this case could influence how utility companies justify their costs and rate increases in the future.
Background
The parties involved in this case include the Washington State Attorney General’s Office, Public Counsel Unit, and the Puyallup Tribe of Indians, who are collectively referred to as the appellants. They appealed a decision made by the WUTC, which authorized PSE to increase its rates to cover costs related to the Tacoma LNG Facility. This facility is designed to liquefy natural gas for storage and distribution, including supplying LNG for marine vessels.
The dispute arose after PSE sought to recover approximately $47.6 million in costs associated with the facility through a rate increase. The Attorney General's Office and the Tribe argued that the Commission made errors in its decision-making process regarding the prudency of these costs and the application of public interest standards.
The case reached the Court of Appeals after the Thurston County Superior Court certified the appeal for judicial review. The appellants contended that the Commission failed to apply the expanded public interest standard to the project and did not adequately consider the redesign costs associated with a contract with Totem Ocean Trailer Express, Inc. (TOTE).
The Ruling
The court ruled on several key issues raised by the appellants. Firstly, it agreed with the appellants that the Commission erred in allowing PSE to recover certain redesign costs associated with TOTE. However, the court disagreed with the appellants' arguments regarding the application of the expanded public interest standard and the determination of PSE’s legal costs.
The court stated, "The Commission should decline to revisit decisions it has already deemed prudent and instead allow the 2022 PSE GRC Order a proper measure of administrative finality."
Regarding the redesign costs, the court found that the Commission should have disallowed all costs associated with the TOTE redesign, as they did not benefit the public. The court noted that the redesign was necessary only to fulfill contractual obligations with TOTE and not for the benefit of PSE's ratepayers.
On the issue of legal costs, the court upheld the Commission's decision to allow PSE's legal fees, finding that there was sufficient evidence in the record to support the Commission's determination that these costs were reasonable.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for how utility companies like PSE can recover costs associated with major projects. By agreeing with the appellants on the redesign costs, the court emphasizes the importance of ensuring that ratepayers are not burdened with costs that do not directly benefit them. This decision could set a precedent for future cases involving utility rate increases and the scrutiny of project costs.
The ruling also reinforces the need for utility companies to demonstrate the prudency of their expenditures when seeking to pass costs onto consumers. The decision highlights the balance that must be struck between allowing utilities to recover reasonable costs and protecting consumers from unjustified rate increases.
What's Next
The case may be appealed to the Washington Supreme Court, although details regarding any potential appeal were not available in the court filing. Additionally, related cases may arise as other utility projects come under scrutiny, particularly those involving significant costs and environmental considerations.
Read Next
Washington Court Affirms Domestic Violence Protection Order
Court rules on Puget Sound Energy rate hike dispute
Court reverses eviction ruling in Seattle housing case
Court rules against Corning in insurance coverage dispute
Ninth Circuit upholds labor arbitration ruling in Oregon case
Florida Court Dismisses Appeal in Property Dispute Case










