The Washington Court of Appeals recently issued a ruling in the case of Linzie Colette Stovall v. Raekwon Deshawn Monterris Davis, No. 60995-9-II, addressing a parenting plan and child support order concerning their son, JD. The court's decision affects both parents and outlines the responsibilities for JD's care and financial support.
Linzie Stovall and Raekwon Davis share a son, JD, who was born in September 2021. Stovall, a surgical technician, and Davis, a professional football player, faced a series of disputes over parenting and financial obligations after their relationship ended. Their case reached the Court of Appeals after Stovall challenged the trial court's decisions regarding the parenting plan and child support order.
The dispute began when Stovall sought a parenting plan and child support after their breakup. The two had previously signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) outlining their agreement on child support payments. However, Davis failed to meet his obligations under the MOU, leading to the trial and subsequent appeal. The trial court had awarded Stovall sole decision-making authority for JD’s care but required both parents to jointly decide on non-routine medical care and extracurricular activities.
Stovall appealed the trial court's decisions, arguing that the court abused its discretion in several areas. She contested the joint decision-making requirement, the visitation plan allowing Davis to take JD out of state, and the child support amount set at $3,400 per month. Stovall also sought to have the MOU rescinded due to Davis's failure to comply with its terms.
The Court of Appeals ruled on the various aspects of the case. The court upheld the trial court's parenting plan, affirming the joint decision-making requirement and the visitation plan. The court stated, "We cannot say that the limited joint decision-making ordered by the trial court is so unreasonable and untenable as to be an abuse of discretion." This means that the court found the trial court's decisions regarding JD's care to be reasonable and in the child's best interest.
However, the court did find that the trial court abused its discretion in setting the child support obligation. The Court of Appeals noted that the trial court's reasoning for the $3,400 monthly payment was insufficient and did not adequately consider Davis's financial resources and standard of living. The court stated, "The trial court abused its discretion in awarding $3,400 per month in child support." As a result, the appellate court reversed the child support order and remanded the case back to the trial court for reconsideration of the monthly support obligation.
Additionally, the appellate court addressed the issue of tax exemptions. The trial court had ordered that Davis and Stovall alternate claiming JD as a dependent for tax purposes. The Court of Appeals found this decision problematic, stating that it lacked sufficient justification and that Stovall, as the primary residential parent, would benefit more from the exemption. The court reversed this part of the ruling as well.
The ruling has significant implications for both Stovall and Davis. It clarifies the responsibilities each parent has regarding JD's care and financial support. The appellate court's decision to remand the child support order means that the trial court must reassess the amount Davis is required to pay, considering his financial situation more thoroughly.
Moving forward, the case sets a precedent for how courts might handle similar disputes involving parenting plans and child support. It emphasizes the importance of considering both parents' financial situations and the child's best interests when determining support obligations.
As for what’s next, the trial court will need to hold a new hearing to determine the appropriate child support amount based on the appellate court's guidance. Stovall and Davis may also have the option to appeal certain aspects of the ruling, but details were not available in the court filing regarding any potential further appeals.
Overall, the Court of Appeals ruling in Linzie Colette Stovall v. Raekwon Deshawn Monterris Davis highlights the complexities of child support and parenting plans, ensuring that both parents are held accountable for their responsibilities while prioritizing the welfare of their child.
Read Next
Washington Court of Appeals rules on LNG facility costs
Court rules on Puget Sound Energy rate hike dispute
Court reverses eviction ruling in Seattle housing case
Vermont court denies motion to amend wrongful death complaint
Vermont court dismisses eviction case against Catherine Morrill
Vermont court rules on timber harvest dispute case









