The Washington Court of Appeals recently ruled on a significant case involving Puget Sound Energy (PSE) and its proposed rate increases. The decision affects PSE's customers and the Puyallup Tribe of Indians, who challenged the rate hike associated with the construction of a liquefied natural gas (LNG) facility in Tacoma. The court's ruling has implications for how utility costs are allocated and the standards applied in determining the prudence of utility expenditures.
The case, formally known as Attorney General's Office v. Utilities & Transportation Commission, was filed on November 17, 2026, under docket number 41077-3-III. The appellants, including the Washington State Attorney General’s Office Public Counsel Unit and the Puyallup Tribe, argued that the Washington Utilities and Transportation Commission (Commission) erred in its approval of PSE's rate increase. This ruling is particularly important as it sets precedents for future utility rate cases and the standards applied in determining the prudence of utility expenditures.
Background
The dispute centers around PSE's construction of a dual-use LNG facility in Tacoma, which was intended to serve both PSE customers and provide LNG for marine vessels. The facility, which includes a large storage tank and various processing equipment, was built to meet the growing demand for natural gas, especially during peak usage times. In 2014, PSE entered into a contract with Totem Ocean Trailer Express, Inc. (TOTE) to supply marine fuel, which necessitated the construction of the facility.
In 2022, PSE filed a general rate case seeking to recover costs associated with the LNG facility, claiming that the investments were prudent and necessary. The Puyallup Tribe and Public Counsel intervened, arguing against the prudence of the facility's construction and the associated costs. They contended that the facility posed environmental and safety risks and that the costs should not be passed on to ratepayers.
The Ruling
The Washington Court of Appeals ultimately ruled on several key issues raised by the appellants. The court agreed with the appellants on the second argument regarding the redesign costs associated with the LNG facility. Specifically, the court found that the redesign costs incurred to meet TOTE's contract obligations did not benefit the public and should not be included in the rate increase. The court stated, "The Commission agreed with the appellants that none of the TOTE redesign costs benefited the public and disallowed those costs." However, the court disagreed with the appellants' arguments regarding the retroactive application of the expanded public interest standard and the application of the lodestar formula for determining legal costs.
Judge Lawrence-Berrey, who authored the opinion, explained that the Commission's decision not to apply the expanded public interest standard retroactively was reasonable. The court emphasized that the Commission should not revisit decisions already deemed prudent and should allow for administrative finality. The court also found that the Commission had sufficient evidence to support its decision regarding PSE's legal costs, allowing those costs to be included in the rate increase.
Impact
This ruling has significant implications for both PSE customers and the regulatory landscape for utilities in Washington. By agreeing to disallow the redesign costs associated with the TOTE contract, the court reinforced the principle that utility costs must benefit the public to be deemed prudent. This decision may influence how future utility projects are evaluated and the standards applied by the Commission in determining what costs can be passed on to ratepayers.
Moreover, the court's ruling on the application of the expanded public interest standard suggests that utilities may not be held to new standards retroactively, providing a measure of predictability for utility investments. This aspect of the ruling could affect how utilities approach future projects and their associated costs.
What's Next
The ruling can potentially be appealed to the Washington Supreme Court. However, details regarding any pending appeals or related cases were not available in the court filing. The outcome of this case will likely influence future rate cases and the regulatory framework governing utility costs in Washington.
Read Next
Washington Court Affirms Domestic Violence Protection Order
Washington Court of Appeals rules on LNG facility costs
Court reverses eviction ruling in Seattle housing case
Court rules against Corning in insurance coverage dispute
Ninth Circuit upholds labor arbitration ruling in Oregon case
Florida Court Dismisses Appeal in Property Dispute Case










